Skip to main content
parlae.ioBeta
Sign in

All-time Blue Jays MLB draft pool

Everyone who played for the Toronto Blue Jays franchise, in every city it has called home. 412 players you can draft, each rated 40 to 99 from real stats. Ratings updated October 10, 2026.

Draft from this pool How the ratings work
Parrish99McGriff99Kent99Rolen99Tulowitzki99Winfield99Thomas99Clemens99Righetti99Henderson97Niekro97Escobar96

CCatchers

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Lance ParrishBlue Jays, Tigers, Angels +4 · 1977-1995.252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI99
  2. 2Mike StanleyBlue Jays, Red Sox, Rangers +2 · 1986-2000.270/.370/.458, 187 HR, 702 RBI93
  3. 3Russell MartinBlue Jays, Dodgers, Yankees +1 · 2006-2019.248/.349/.397, 191 HR, 771 RBI90
  4. 4Benito SantiagoBlue Jays, Padres, Giants +6 · 1986-2005.263/.307/.415, 217 HR, 920 RBI88
  5. 5Miguel MonteroBlue Jays, Diamondbacks, Cubs +1 · 2006-2018.256/.340/.411, 126 HR, 550 RBI86
  6. 6Bob BrenlyBlue Jays, Giants · 1981-1989.247/.330/.403, 91 HR, 333 RBI85
  7. 7Ernie WhittBlue Jays, Braves, Orioles +1 · 1976-1991.249/.324/.410, 134 HR, 534 RBI83
  8. 8Ozzie VirgilBlue Jays, Phillies, Braves · 1980-1990.243/.324/.416, 98 HR, 307 RBI82
  9. 9Darrin FletcherBlue Jays, Nationals, Phillies +1 · 1989-2002.269/.318/.423, 124 HR, 583 RBI81
  10. 10Michael BarrettBlue Jays, Nationals, Cubs +1 · 1998-2009.263/.320/.422, 98 HR, 424 RBI81
  11. 11Alan AshbyBlue Jays, Astros, Guardians · 1973-1989.245/.320/.361, 90 HR, 513 RBI80
  12. 12Alejandro KirkBlue Jays · 2020-2025.268/.345/.398, 51 HR, 263 RBI79
  13. 13Bengie MolinaBlue Jays, Angels, Giants +1 · 1998-2010.274/.307/.411, 144 HR, 711 RBI78
  14. 14Yan GomesBlue Jays, Guardians, Cubs +2 · 2012-2024.246/.295/.412, 137 HR, 517 RBI78
  15. 15Gregg ZaunBlue Jays, Marlins, Orioles +6 · 1995-2010.252/.344/.388, 88 HR, 446 RBI77
  16. 16Jarrod SaltalamacchiaBlue Jays, Red Sox, Rangers +4 · 2007-2018.232/.306/.408, 110 HR, 381 RBI77
  17. 17Charlie MooreBlue Jays, Brewers · 1973-1987.261/.319/.355, 36 HR, 408 RBI76
  18. 18John BuckBlue Jays, Royals, Marlins +4 · 2004-2014.234/.301/.398, 134 HR, 491 RBI76
  19. 19Danny JansenBlue Jays, Rays, Red Sox +1 · 2018-2025.220/.311/.415, 88 HR, 256 RBI75
  20. 20Dioner NavarroBlue Jays, Rays, Dodgers +4 · 2004-2016.250/.309/.370, 77 HR, 367 RBI75
  21. 21Geno PetralliBlue Jays, Rangers · 1982-1993.267/.344/.360, 24 HR, 192 RBI75
  22. 22Gabriel MorenoBlue Jays, Diamondbacks · 2022-2025.281/.349/.404, 22 HR, 142 RBI74
  23. 23Greg MyersBlue Jays, Angels, Twins +4 · 1987-2005.255/.313/.395, 87 HR, 396 RBI74
  24. 24Yorvit TorrealbaBlue Jays, Rockies, Giants +4 · 2001-2013.256/.315/.379, 56 HR, 339 RBI74
  25. 25Bobby EstalellaBlue Jays, Giants, Rockies +3 · 1996-2004.216/.315/.440, 48 HR, 147 RBI73

1BFirst basemans

Top 25 of 25
  1. 1Fred McGriffBlue Jays, Braves, Rays +3 · 1986-2004.284/.377/.509, 493 HR, 1,550 RBI99
  2. 2Carlos DelgadoBlue Jays, Mets, Marlins · 1993-2009.280/.383/.546, 473 HR, 1,512 RBI93
  3. 3John OlerudBlue Jays, Mariners, Mets +2 · 1989-2005.295/.398/.465, 255 HR, 1,230 RBI90
  4. 4John MayberryBlue Jays, Royals, Astros +1 · 1968-1982.253/.360/.439, 255 HR, 879 RBI88
  5. 5Ron FairlyBlue Jays, Dodgers, Nationals +3 · 1958-1978.266/.360/.408, 215 HR, 1,044 RBI86
  6. 6Vladimir GuerreroBlue Jays · 2019-2025.288/.366/.495, 183 HR, 591 RBI85
  7. 7Cecil FielderBlue Jays, Tigers, Yankees +2 · 1985-1998.255/.345/.482, 319 HR, 1,008 RBI83
  8. 8Brandon BeltBlue Jays, Giants · 2011-2023.261/.357/.460, 194 HR, 627 RBI82
  9. 9Adam LindBlue Jays, Brewers, Mariners +1 · 2006-2017.272/.330/.465, 200 HR, 723 RBI81
  10. 10David SeguiBlue Jays, Orioles, Nationals +4 · 1990-2004.291/.359/.443, 139 HR, 684 RBI81
  11. 11Kevin MillarBlue Jays, Marlins, Red Sox +1 · 1998-2009.274/.358/.452, 170 HR, 699 RBI80
  12. 12Lyle OverbayBlue Jays, Brewers, Diamondbacks +3 · 2001-2014.266/.347/.429, 151 HR, 675 RBI79
  13. 13Willie AikensBlue Jays, Royals, Angels · 1977-1985.271/.354/.455, 110 HR, 415 RBI78
  14. 14Willie UpshawBlue Jays, Guardians · 1978-1988.262/.335/.419, 123 HR, 528 RBI78
  15. 15Bob RobertsonBlue Jays, Pirates, Mariners · 1967-1979.242/.331/.434, 115 HR, 368 RBI77
  16. 16Justin SmoakBlue Jays, Mariners, Rangers +2 · 2010-2020.229/.322/.419, 196 HR, 570 RBI77
  17. 17Pat TablerBlue Jays, Guardians, Royals +2 · 1981-1992.282/.345/.379, 47 HR, 512 RBI76
  18. 18Ty FranceBlue Jays, Mariners, Twins +2 · 2019-2025.262/.334/.400, 81 HR, 364 RBI76
  19. 19Dave ReveringBlue Jays, Athletics, Yankees +1 · 1978-1982.265/.318/.430, 62 HR, 234 RBI75
  20. 20Eric ThamesBlue Jays, Brewers, Nationals +1 · 2011-2020.241/.325/.467, 96 HR, 235 RBI75
  21. 21Tony SolaitaBlue Jays, Angels, Royals +2 · 1968-1979.255/.357/.421, 50 HR, 203 RBI75
  22. 22Craig KusickBlue Jays, Twins · 1973-1979.235/.342/.392, 46 HR, 171 RBI74
  23. 23Dan JohnsonBlue Jays, Athletics, Rays +3 · 2005-2015.234/.335/.405, 57 HR, 203 RBI74
  24. 24Rowdy TellezBlue Jays, Brewers, Pirates +2 · 2018-2025.234/.300/.437, 122 HR, 368 RBI74
  25. 25Tom HuttonBlue Jays, Phillies, Nationals +1 · 1966-1981.248/.339/.334, 22 HR, 186 RBI73

2BSecond basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Jeff KentBlue Jays, Giants, Dodgers +3 · 1992-2008.290/.356/.500, 377 HR, 1,518 RBI99
  2. 2Roberto AlomarBlue Jays, Guardians, Padres +4 · 1988-2004.300/.371/.443, 210 HR, 1,134 RBI93
  3. 3Juan SamuelBlue Jays, Phillies, Dodgers +4 · 1983-1998.259/.315/.420, 161 HR, 703 RBI90
  4. 4Jorge OrtaBlue Jays, White Sox, Royals +2 · 1972-1987.278/.334/.412, 130 HR, 745 RBI88
  5. 5Aaron HillBlue Jays, Diamondbacks, Brewers +2 · 2005-2017.266/.323/.417, 162 HR, 695 RBI86
  6. 6Kelly JohnsonBlue Jays, Braves, Diamondbacks +5 · 2005-2016.251/.330/.422, 155 HR, 550 RBI85
  7. 7Orlando HudsonBlue Jays, Diamondbacks, Padres +3 · 2002-2012.273/.341/.412, 93 HR, 542 RBI83
  8. 8Whit MerrifieldBlue Jays, Royals, Phillies +1 · 2016-2024.280/.328/.413, 94 HR, 485 RBI82
  9. 9Mariano DuncanBlue Jays, Phillies, Dodgers +2 · 1985-1997.267/.300/.388, 87 HR, 491 RBI81
  10. 10Mickey MorandiniBlue Jays, Phillies, Cubs · 1990-2000.268/.338/.359, 32 HR, 351 RBI81
  11. 11Brandon DruryBlue Jays, Diamondbacks, Angels +4 · 2015-2024.245/.296/.421, 109 HR, 375 RBI80
  12. 12Joe PanikBlue Jays, Giants, Marlins +1 · 2014-2021.264/.328/.372, 42 HR, 258 RBI79
  13. 13Andres GimenezBlue Jays, Guardians, Mets · 2020-2025.253/.317/.382, 56 HR, 257 RBI78
  14. 14Damaso GarciaBlue Jays, Nationals, Yankees +1 · 1978-1989.283/.309/.371, 36 HR, 323 RBI78
  15. 15Cavan BiggioBlue Jays, Royals, Dodgers +1 · 2019-2025.223/.339/.373, 52 HR, 190 RBI77
  16. 16Jeff FryeBlue Jays, Red Sox, Rangers +1 · 1992-2001.290/.357/.386, 16 HR, 194 RBI77
  17. 17Devon TravisBlue Jays · 2015-2018.274/.314/.437, 35 HR, 153 RBI76
  18. 18Nelson LirianoBlue Jays, Pirates, Rockies +3 · 1987-1998.260/.324/.366, 25 HR, 240 RBI76
  19. 19Carlos GarciaBlue Jays, Pirates, Angels +1 · 1990-1999.266/.307/.374, 33 HR, 197 RBI75
  20. 20Craig GrebeckBlue Jays, White Sox, Angels +2 · 1990-2001.261/.340/.356, 19 HR, 187 RBI75
  21. 21Frank MenechinoBlue Jays, Athletics · 1999-2005.240/.358/.383, 36 HR, 149 RBI75
  22. 22Dave BergBlue Jays, Marlins · 1998-2004.269/.328/.372, 21 HR, 163 RBI74
  23. 23Eric SogardBlue Jays, Athletics, Brewers +2 · 2010-2021.246/.313/.338, 26 HR, 187 RBI74
  24. 24Miguel CairoBlue Jays, Rays, Reds +6 · 1996-2012.264/.314/.361, 41 HR, 394 RBI74
  25. 25Darwin BarneyBlue Jays, Cubs, Dodgers · 2010-2017.246/.294/.341, 31 HR, 201 RBI73

Advertisement

3BThird basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Scott RolenBlue Jays, Phillies, Cardinals +1 · 1996-2012.281/.364/.490, 316 HR, 1,287 RBI99
  2. 2Josh DonaldsonBlue Jays, Athletics, Yankees +4 · 2010-2023.261/.358/.489, 279 HR, 816 RBI93
  3. 3Troy GlausBlue Jays, Angels, Cardinals +2 · 1998-2010.254/.358/.489, 320 HR, 950 RBI90
  4. 4Justin TurnerBlue Jays, Dodgers, Mets +4 · 2009-2025.283/.360/.454, 201 HR, 832 RBI88
  5. 5Edgardo AlfonzoBlue Jays, Mets, Giants +1 · 1995-2006.284/.357/.425, 146 HR, 744 RBI86
  6. 6Matt ChapmanBlue Jays, Athletics, Giants · 2017-2025.240/.330/.458, 203 HR, 565 RBI85
  7. 7Doug RaderBlue Jays, Astros, Padres · 1967-1977.251/.322/.403, 155 HR, 722 RBI83
  8. 8Corey KoskieBlue Jays, Twins, Brewers · 1998-2006.275/.367/.458, 124 HR, 506 RBI82
  9. 9Casey BlakeBlue Jays, Guardians, Dodgers +2 · 1999-2011.264/.336/.442, 167 HR, 616 RBI81
  10. 10Dave HollinsBlue Jays, Phillies, Angels +4 · 1990-2002.260/.358/.420, 112 HR, 482 RBI81
  11. 11Rance MulliniksBlue Jays, Angels, Royals · 1977-1992.272/.354/.407, 73 HR, 435 RBI80
  12. 12Kelly GruberBlue Jays, Angels · 1984-1993.259/.307/.432, 117 HR, 443 RBI79
  13. 13Eric HinskeBlue Jays, Braves, Rays +4 · 2002-2013.249/.332/.430, 137 HR, 522 RBI78
  14. 14Shea HillenbrandBlue Jays, Red Sox, Diamondbacks +3 · 2001-2007.284/.321/.440, 108 HR, 490 RBI78
  15. 15Mark DeRosaBlue Jays, Braves, Cubs +5 · 1998-2013.268/.340/.412, 100 HR, 494 RBI77
  16. 16Tony BatistaBlue Jays, Orioles, Nationals +3 · 1996-2007.251/.299/.453, 221 HR, 718 RBI77
  17. 17Roy HowellBlue Jays, Brewers, Rangers · 1974-1984.261/.321/.389, 80 HR, 454 RBI76
  18. 18Travis ShawBlue Jays, Brewers, Red Sox · 2015-2022.237/.319/.437, 114 HR, 366 RBI76
  19. 19Danny ValenciaBlue Jays, Twins, Athletics +4 · 2010-2018.268/.317/.426, 96 HR, 397 RBI75
  20. 20Ed SpragueBlue Jays, Pirates, Padres +3 · 1991-2001.247/.318/.419, 152 HR, 558 RBI75
  21. 21Jake LambBlue Jays, Diamondbacks, White Sox +4 · 2014-2023.235/.326/.427, 96 HR, 342 RBI75
  22. 22Gio UrshelaBlue Jays, Yankees, Guardians +5 · 2015-2025.270/.314/.407, 73 HR, 352 RBI74
  23. 23Mark TeahenBlue Jays, Royals, White Sox · 2005-2011.264/.327/.409, 67 HR, 332 RBI74
  24. 24Yangervis SolarteBlue Jays, Padres, Yankees +1 · 2014-2019.258/.315/.408, 75 HR, 307 RBI74
  25. 25Brett LawrieBlue Jays, Athletics, White Sox · 2011-2016.261/.315/.419, 71 HR, 253 RBI73

SSShortstops

Top 25 of 33
  1. 1Troy TulowitzkiBlue Jays, Rockies, Yankees · 2006-2019.290/.361/.495, 225 HR, 780 RBI99
  2. 2Jose ReyesBlue Jays, Mets, Marlins +1 · 2003-2018.283/.334/.427, 145 HR, 719 RBI93
  3. 3Tony FernandezBlue Jays, Padres, Guardians +4 · 1983-2001.288/.347/.399, 94 HR, 844 RBI90
  4. 4Marcus SemienBlue Jays, Athletics, Rangers +1 · 2013-2025.253/.321/.435, 253 HR, 801 RBI88
  5. 5Bo BichetteBlue Jays · 2019-2025.294/.337/.469, 111 HR, 437 RBI86
  6. 6Yunel EscobarBlue Jays, Braves, Rays +2 · 2007-2017.282/.350/.386, 90 HR, 519 RBI85
  7. 7Marco ScutaroBlue Jays, Athletics, Red Sox +3 · 2002-2014.277/.341/.388, 77 HR, 509 RBI83
  8. 8Omar VizquelBlue Jays, Guardians, Mariners +3 · 1989-2012.272/.336/.352, 80 HR, 951 RBI82
  9. 9Felipe LopezBlue Jays, Reds, Nationals +5 · 2001-2011.264/.333/.391, 90 HR, 439 RBI81
  10. 10Jonathan VillarBlue Jays, Brewers, Orioles +5 · 2013-2022.255/.322/.397, 101 HR, 343 RBI81
  11. 11David EcksteinBlue Jays, Angels, Cardinals +2 · 2001-2010.280/.345/.355, 35 HR, 392 RBI80
  12. 12Paul DeJongBlue Jays, Cardinals, White Sox +3 · 2017-2025.229/.294/.416, 146 HR, 423 RBI79
  13. 13Aledmys DiazBlue Jays, Astros, Cardinals +1 · 2016-2024.259/.312/.424, 78 HR, 294 RBI78
  14. 14Royce ClaytonBlue Jays, Giants, Cardinals +8 · 1991-2007.258/.312/.367, 110 HR, 723 RBI78
  15. 15Alex GonzalezBlue Jays, Marlins, Braves +4 · 1998-2014.245/.290/.395, 157 HR, 690 RBI77
  16. 16Mike BordickBlue Jays, Athletics, Orioles +1 · 1990-2003.260/.323/.362, 91 HR, 626 RBI77
  17. 17Chris GomezBlue Jays, Padres, Tigers +5 · 1993-2008.262/.325/.360, 60 HR, 487 RBI76
  18. 18Freddy GalvisBlue Jays, Phillies, Padres +2 · 2012-2021.246/.292/.387, 109 HR, 426 RBI76
  19. 19Alex GonzalezBlue Jays, Cubs, Rays +3 · 1994-2006.243/.302/.391, 137 HR, 536 RBI75
  20. 20Cliff PenningtonBlue Jays, Athletics, Diamondbacks +2 · 2008-2018.242/.309/.339, 36 HR, 242 RBI75
  21. 21Isiah Kiner-FalefaBlue Jays, Rangers, Yankees +1 · 2018-2025.262/.311/.349, 36 HR, 286 RBI75
  22. 22Adeiny HechavarriaBlue Jays, Marlins, Rays +4 · 2012-2020.253/.291/.351, 37 HR, 273 RBI74
  23. 23Chris WoodwardBlue Jays, Mets, Braves +2 · 1999-2011.239/.296/.365, 33 HR, 191 RBI74
  24. 24Manuel LeeBlue Jays, Rangers, Cardinals · 1985-1995.255/.305/.323, 19 HR, 249 RBI74
  25. 25Alfredo GriffinBlue Jays, Dodgers, Athletics +1 · 1976-1993.249/.285/.319, 24 HR, 527 RBI73

OFOutfielders

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Dave WinfieldBlue Jays, Yankees, Padres +3 · 1973-1995.283/.353/.475, 465 HR, 1,833 RBI99
  2. 2Rickey HendersonBlue Jays, Athletics, Yankees +6 · 1979-2003.279/.401/.419, 297 HR, 1,115 RBI97
  3. 3Dave ParkerBlue Jays, Pirates, Reds +3 · 1973-1991.290/.339/.471, 339 HR, 1,493 RBI95
  4. 4Al OliverBlue Jays, Pirates, Rangers +4 · 1968-1985.303/.344/.451, 219 HR, 1,326 RBI93
  5. 5Jose CansecoBlue Jays, Athletics, Red Sox +4 · 1985-2001.266/.353/.515, 462 HR, 1,407 RBI92
  6. 6Jose BautistaBlue Jays, Pirates, Mets +5 · 2004-2018.247/.361/.475, 344 HR, 975 RBI91
  7. 7Willie HortonBlue Jays, Tigers, Mariners +3 · 1963-1980.273/.332/.457, 325 HR, 1,163 RBI90
  8. 8Rico CartyBlue Jays, Braves, Guardians +3 · 1963-1979.299/.369/.464, 204 HR, 890 RBI89
  9. 9Shawn GreenBlue Jays, Dodgers, Diamondbacks +1 · 1993-2007.283/.355/.494, 328 HR, 1,070 RBI89
  10. 10Jeff BurroughsBlue Jays, Rangers, Braves +2 · 1970-1985.261/.355/.439, 240 HR, 882 RBI88
  11. 11Curtis GrandersonBlue Jays, Tigers, Mets +4 · 2004-2019.249/.337/.465, 344 HR, 937 RBI87
  12. 12George SpringerBlue Jays, Astros · 2014-2025.266/.353/.478, 293 HR, 796 RBI87
  13. 13George BellBlue Jays, White Sox, Cubs · 1981-1993.278/.316/.469, 265 HR, 1,002 RBI86
  14. 14Jayson WerthBlue Jays, Nationals, Phillies +1 · 2002-2017.267/.360/.455, 229 HR, 799 RBI86
  15. 15Joe CarterBlue Jays, Guardians, Padres +3 · 1983-1998.259/.306/.464, 396 HR, 1,445 RBI85
  16. 16Ruben SierraBlue Jays, Rangers, Yankees +6 · 1986-2006.268/.315/.450, 306 HR, 1,322 RBI85
  17. 17Raul MondesiBlue Jays, Dodgers, Yankees +4 · 1993-2005.273/.331/.485, 271 HR, 860 RBI84
  18. 18Tony PhillipsBlue Jays, Athletics, Tigers +3 · 1982-1999.266/.374/.389, 160 HR, 819 RBI84
  19. 19Jesse BarfieldBlue Jays, Yankees · 1981-1992.256/.335/.466, 241 HR, 716 RBI83
  20. 20Matt StairsBlue Jays, Athletics, Royals +9 · 1992-2011.262/.356/.477, 265 HR, 899 RBI83
  21. 21Vernon WellsBlue Jays, Angels, Yankees · 1999-2013.270/.319/.459, 270 HR, 958 RBI83
  22. 22Alex RiosBlue Jays, White Sox, Rangers +1 · 2004-2015.277/.321/.434, 169 HR, 794 RBI82
  23. 23Lloyd MosebyBlue Jays, Tigers · 1980-1991.257/.332/.414, 169 HR, 737 RBI82
  24. 24Melky CabreraBlue Jays, Yankees, White Sox +5 · 2005-2019.285/.334/.417, 144 HR, 854 RBI82
  25. 25Devon WhiteBlue Jays, Angels, Marlins +3 · 1985-2001.263/.319/.419, 208 HR, 846 RBI81

DHDesignated hitters

Top 9 of 9
  1. 1Frank ThomasBlue Jays, White Sox, Athletics · 1990-2008.301/.419/.555, 521 HR, 1,704 RBI99
  2. 2Paul MolitorBlue Jays, Brewers, Twins · 1978-1998.306/.369/.448, 234 HR, 1,307 RBI93
  3. 3Edwin EncarnacionBlue Jays, Reds, Guardians +3 · 2005-2020.260/.350/.496, 424 HR, 1,261 RBI90
  4. 4Cliff JohnsonBlue Jays, Astros, Yankees +4 · 1972-1986.258/.355/.459, 196 HR, 699 RBI88
  5. 5Kendrys MoralesBlue Jays, Angels, Royals +4 · 2006-2019.265/.327/.453, 213 HR, 740 RBI86
  6. 6Brad FullmerBlue Jays, Nationals, Angels +1 · 1997-2004.279/.336/.486, 114 HR, 442 RBI85
  7. 7Dan VogelbachBlue Jays, Mariners, Mets +2 · 2016-2024.219/.340/.405, 81 HR, 246 RBI83
  8. 8Josh PhelpsBlue Jays, Pirates, Rays +3 · 2000-2008.273/.343/.472, 64 HR, 244 RBI82
  9. 9Glenn AdamsBlue Jays, Twins, Giants · 1975-1982.280/.324/.398, 34 HR, 225 RBI81

SPStarting pitchers

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Roger ClemensBlue Jays, Red Sox, Yankees +1 · 1984-2007354-184, 3.12 ERA, 4,672 K99
  2. 2Phil NiekroBlue Jays, Braves, Yankees +1 · 1964-1987318-274, 3.35 ERA, 3,342 K97
  3. 3Roy HalladayBlue Jays, Phillies · 1998-2013203-105, 3.38 ERA, 2,117 K95
  4. 4Max ScherzerBlue Jays, Nationals, Tigers +4 · 2008-2025221-117, 3.22 ERA, 3,489 K93
  5. 5David ConeBlue Jays, Mets, Yankees +2 · 1986-2003194-126, 3.46 ERA, 2,668 K92
  6. 6Dave StiebBlue Jays, White Sox · 1979-1998176-137, 3.44 ERA, 1,669 K91
  7. 7Jack MorrisBlue Jays, Tigers, Twins +1 · 1977-1994254-186, 3.90 ERA, 2,478 K90
  8. 8Jimmy KeyBlue Jays, Yankees, Orioles · 1984-1998186-117, 3.51 ERA, 1,538 K89
  9. 9Mark BuehrleBlue Jays, White Sox, Marlins · 2000-2015214-160, 3.81 ERA, 1,870 K89
  10. 10David WellsBlue Jays, Yankees, Tigers +6 · 1987-2007239-157, 4.13 ERA, 2,201 K88
  11. 11David PriceBlue Jays, Rays, Red Sox +2 · 2008-2022157-82, 3.32 ERA, 2,076 K87
  12. 12Frank ViolaBlue Jays, Twins, Mets +2 · 1982-1996176-150, 3.73 ERA, 1,844 K87
  13. 13Al LeiterBlue Jays, Mets, Marlins +1 · 1987-2005162-132, 3.80 ERA, 1,974 K86
  14. 14Chris CarpenterBlue Jays, Cardinals · 1997-2012144-94, 3.76 ERA, 1,697 K86
  15. 15Pat HentgenBlue Jays, Orioles, Cardinals · 1991-2004131-112, 4.32 ERA, 1,290 K85
  16. 16Tom CandiottiBlue Jays, Dodgers, Guardians +2 · 1983-1999151-164, 3.73 ERA, 1,735 K85
  17. 17Danny DarwinBlue Jays, Astros, Rangers +5 · 1978-1998171-182, 3.84 ERA, 1,942 K84
  18. 18Doyle AlexanderBlue Jays, Orioles, Rangers +5 · 1971-1989194-174, 3.76 ERA, 1,528 K84
  19. 19Dave StewartBlue Jays, Athletics, Dodgers +2 · 1978-1995168-129, 3.95 ERA, 1,741 K83
  20. 20John CandelariaBlue Jays, Pirates, Dodgers +5 · 1975-1993177-122, 3.33 ERA, 1,673 K83
  21. 21Mike FlanaganBlue Jays, Orioles · 1975-1992167-143, 3.90 ERA, 1,491 K83
  22. 22A. J. BurnettBlue Jays, Marlins, Yankees +2 · 1999-2015164-157, 3.99 ERA, 2,513 K82
  23. 23Kevin GausmanBlue Jays, Orioles, Giants +2 · 2013-2025112-113, 3.81 ERA, 1,954 K82
  24. 24Woody WilliamsBlue Jays, Padres, Cardinals +1 · 1993-2007132-116, 4.19 ERA, 1,480 K82
  25. 25Bill SingerBlue Jays, Dodgers, Angels +2 · 1964-1977118-127, 3.39 ERA, 1,515 K81

RPRelief pitchers

Top 25 of 60
  1. 1Dave RighettiBlue Jays, Yankees, Giants +2 · 1979-1995252 SV, 3.46 ERA, 1,112 K99
  2. 2Kelvim EscobarBlue Jays, Angels · 1997-200959 SV, 4.15 ERA, 1,310 K96
  3. 3Tom HenkeBlue Jays, Rangers, Cardinals · 1982-1995311 SV, 2.67 ERA, 861 K93
  4. 4Armando BenitezBlue Jays, Mets, Orioles +4 · 1994-2008289 SV, 3.13 ERA, 946 K92
  5. 5Francisco CorderoBlue Jays, Rangers, Reds +3 · 1999-2012329 SV, 3.38 ERA, 796 K90
  6. 6Mike TimlinBlue Jays, Red Sox, Cardinals +3 · 1991-2008141 SV, 3.63 ERA, 872 K89
  7. 7Randy MyersBlue Jays, Mets, Cubs +3 · 1985-1998347 SV, 3.19 ERA, 884 K88
  8. 8Joakim SoriaBlue Jays, Royals, Athletics +6 · 2007-2021229 SV, 3.11 ERA, 831 K87
  9. 9Paul QuantrillBlue Jays, Dodgers, Yankees +4 · 1992-200521 SV, 3.83 ERA, 725 K86
  10. 10Gary LavelleBlue Jays, Giants, Athletics · 1974-1987136 SV, 2.93 ERA, 769 K85
  11. 11Mark EichhornBlue Jays, Angels, Braves +1 · 1982-199632 SV, 3.00 ERA, 640 K85
  12. 12LaTroy HawkinsBlue Jays, Twins, Rockies +8 · 1995-2015127 SV, 4.31 ERA, 983 K84
  13. 13Dan PlesacBlue Jays, Brewers, Pirates +3 · 1986-2003158 SV, 3.64 ERA, 1,041 K83
  14. 14Darren OliverBlue Jays, Rangers, Angels +6 · 1993-20137 SV, 4.51 ERA, 1,259 K83
  15. 15Miguel BatistaBlue Jays, Nationals, Diamondbacks +8 · 1992-201241 SV, 4.48 ERA, 1,250 K82
  16. 16Octavio DotelBlue Jays, Astros, White Sox +10 · 1999-2013109 SV, 3.78 ERA, 1,143 K82
  17. 17Dennis LampBlue Jays, Red Sox, Cubs +3 · 1977-199235 SV, 3.93 ERA, 857 K81
  18. 18Joaquin BenoitBlue Jays, Rangers, Tigers +5 · 2001-201753 SV, 3.83 ERA, 1,058 K81
  19. 19Tyler ClippardBlue Jays, Nationals, Yankees +7 · 2007-202274 SV, 3.16 ERA, 956 K81
  20. 20B. J. RyanBlue Jays, Orioles, Reds · 1999-2009117 SV, 3.37 ERA, 625 K80
  21. 21David WeathersBlue Jays, Reds, Brewers +6 · 1991-200975 SV, 4.25 ERA, 976 K80
  22. 22Duane WardBlue Jays, Braves · 1986-1995121 SV, 3.28 ERA, 679 K79
  23. 23Joe SmithBlue Jays, Guardians, Angels +5 · 2007-202230 SV, 3.14 ERA, 666 K79
  24. 24Sergio RomoBlue Jays, Giants, Rays +5 · 2008-2022137 SV, 3.21 ERA, 789 K79
  25. 25Brad HandBlue Jays, Padres, Guardians +6 · 2011-2023132 SV, 3.75 ERA, 782 K78

About this pool

Who is the highest rated player in the All-time Blue Jays pool?
Lance Parrish (catcher, Blue Jays, Tigers +5) at 99, from .252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI.
Who is the best catcher to draft from the All-time Blue Jays pool?
Lance Parrish is rated 99: .252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI.
Who is the best first baseman to draft from the All-time Blue Jays pool?
Fred McGriff is rated 99: .284/.377/.509, 493 HR, 1,550 RBI.
Who is the best second baseman to draft from the All-time Blue Jays pool?
Jeff Kent is rated 99: .290/.356/.500, 377 HR, 1,518 RBI.
Who is the best third baseman to draft from the All-time Blue Jays pool?
Scott Rolen is rated 99: .281/.364/.490, 316 HR, 1,287 RBI.
How many players can be drafted from the All-time Blue Jays pool?
412 players, the best at each position deep enough for eight teams to fill every lineup slot about three times over. Everyone who played for the Toronto Blue Jays franchise, in every city it has called home.

Other MLB pools