Skip to main content
parlae.ioBeta
Sign in

All-time Guardians MLB draft pool

Everyone who played for the Cleveland Guardians franchise, in every city it has called home. 426 players you can draft, each rated 40 to 99 from real stats. Ratings updated October 10, 2026.

Draft from this pool How the ratings work
Parrish99Thome99Lajoie99Ramirez99Boudreau99Speaker99Baines99Young99Eckersley99Robinson97Feller97Wilhelm96

CCatchers

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Lance ParrishGuardians, Tigers, Angels +4 · 1977-1995.252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI99
  2. 2Sherm LollarGuardians, White Sox, Orioles +1 · 1946-1963.264/.357/.402, 155 HR, 808 RBI93
  3. 3John RomanoGuardians, White Sox, Cardinals · 1958-1967.255/.354/.443, 129 HR, 417 RBI90
  4. 4Frankie HayesGuardians, Athletics, Orioles +2 · 1933-1947.259/.343/.400, 119 HR, 628 RBI88
  5. 5Del CrandallGuardians, Braves, Giants +1 · 1949-1966.254/.312/.404, 179 HR, 657 RBI86
  6. 6Deacon McGuireGuardians, WAS, Yankees +5 · 1885-1912.278/.340/.370, 36 HR, 708 RBI85
  7. 7Tony PeñaGuardians, Pirates, Red Sox +3 · 1980-1997.260/.309/.364, 107 HR, 708 RBI83
  8. 8Wilson RamosGuardians, Nationals, Mets +4 · 2010-2021.271/.318/.432, 136 HR, 534 RBI82
  9. 9Duke SimsGuardians, Dodgers, Tigers +2 · 1964-1974.239/.340/.401, 100 HR, 310 RBI81
  10. 10Steve O'NeillGuardians, Red Sox, Orioles +1 · 1911-1928.263/.349/.337, 13 HR, 537 RBI81
  11. 11Ron HasseyGuardians, Athletics, Yankees +3 · 1978-1991.266/.340/.382, 71 HR, 438 RBI80
  12. 12Johnny BasslerGuardians, Tigers · 1913-1927.304/.416/.361, 1 HR, 318 RBI79
  13. 13Ed TaubenseeGuardians, Reds, Astros · 1991-2001.273/.331/.430, 94 HR, 419 RBI78
  14. 14Sandy AlomarGuardians, White Sox, Rangers +4 · 1988-2007.273/.309/.406, 112 HR, 588 RBI78
  15. 15Alan AshbyGuardians, Astros, Blue Jays · 1973-1989.245/.320/.361, 90 HR, 513 RBI77
  16. 16Bo DiazGuardians, Reds, Phillies +1 · 1977-1989.255/.297/.387, 87 HR, 452 RBI77
  17. 17Birdie TebbettsGuardians, Tigers, Red Sox · 1936-1952.270/.341/.358, 38 HR, 469 RBI76
  18. 18Ray FosseGuardians, Athletics, Brewers +1 · 1967-1979.256/.306/.367, 61 HR, 324 RBI76
  19. 19Al LopezGuardians, Dodgers, Pirates +1 · 1928-1947.261/.326/.337, 51 HR, 652 RBI75
  20. 20Ossee SchrecongostGuardians, Athletics, Red Sox +4 · 1897-1908.271/.297/.345, 9 HR, 338 RBI75
  21. 21Yan GomesGuardians, Cubs, Nationals +2 · 2012-2024.246/.295/.412, 137 HR, 517 RBI75
  22. 22Billy SullivanGuardians, White Sox, Orioles +4 · 1931-1947.289/.346/.395, 29 HR, 388 RBI74
  23. 23Buddy RosarGuardians, Athletics, Yankees +1 · 1939-1951.261/.330/.334, 18 HR, 367 RBI74
  24. 24Jay ClarkeGuardians, Orioles, Phillies +2 · 1905-1920.254/.318/.333, 6 HR, 127 RBI74
  25. 25Joe AzcueGuardians, Angels, Athletics +3 · 1960-1972.252/.304/.344, 50 HR, 304 RBI73

1BFirst basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Jim ThomeGuardians, White Sox, Phillies +3 · 1991-2012.276/.402/.554, 612 HR, 1,699 RBI99
  2. 2Eddie MurrayGuardians, Orioles, Dodgers +2 · 1977-1997.287/.359/.476, 504 HR, 1,917 RBI93
  3. 3Jason GiambiGuardians, Athletics, Yankees +1 · 1995-2014.277/.399/.516, 440 HR, 1,441 RBI90
  4. 4Keith HernandezGuardians, Cardinals, Mets · 1974-1990.296/.384/.436, 162 HR, 1,071 RBI88
  5. 5Boog PowellGuardians, Orioles, Dodgers · 1961-1977.266/.361/.462, 339 HR, 1,187 RBI86
  6. 6Mickey VernonGuardians, Twins, Red Sox +2 · 1939-1960.286/.359/.428, 172 HR, 1,311 RBI85
  7. 7Harry DavisGuardians, Athletics, Pirates +3 · 1895-1917.277/.335/.408, 75 HR, 951 RBI83
  8. 8Hal TroskyGuardians, White Sox · 1933-1946.302/.371/.522, 228 HR, 1,012 RBI82
  9. 9Carlos SantanaGuardians, Royals, Phillies +5 · 2010-2025.241/.352/.425, 335 HR, 1,136 RBI81
  10. 10Joe AdcockGuardians, Braves, Reds +1 · 1950-1966.277/.337/.485, 336 HR, 1,122 RBI81
  11. 11George BurnsGuardians, Tigers, Athletics +2 · 1914-1929.307/.354/.429, 72 HR, 951 RBI80
  12. 12Ferris FainGuardians, Athletics, White Sox +1 · 1947-1955.290/.424/.396, 48 HR, 570 RBI79
  13. 13Cecil FielderGuardians, Tigers, Blue Jays +2 · 1985-1998.255/.345/.482, 319 HR, 1,008 RBI78
  14. 14Mike HargroveGuardians, Rangers, Padres · 1974-1985.290/.396/.391, 80 HR, 686 RBI78
  15. 15Chris ChamblissGuardians, Braves, Yankees · 1971-1988.279/.334/.415, 185 HR, 972 RBI77
  16. 16Richie SexsonGuardians, Brewers, Mariners +2 · 1997-2008.261/.344/.507, 306 HR, 943 RBI77
  17. 17Jim GentileGuardians, Orioles, Athletics +2 · 1957-1966.260/.368/.486, 179 HR, 549 RBI76
  18. 18Stuffy McInnisGuardians, Athletics, Red Sox +3 · 1909-1927.307/.343/.381, 20 HR, 1,063 RBI76
  19. 19Charlie HickmanGuardians, Twins, Giants +4 · 1897-1908.295/.331/.440, 59 HR, 614 RBI75
  20. 20Eddie RobinsonGuardians, White Sox, Athletics +4 · 1942-1957.268/.353/.440, 172 HR, 723 RBI75
  21. 21Sean CaseyGuardians, Reds, Tigers +2 · 1997-2008.302/.367/.447, 130 HR, 735 RBI75
  22. 22Joe HarrisGuardians, Red Sox, Twins +3 · 1914-1928.317/.404/.472, 47 HR, 517 RBI74
  23. 23Mike NapoliGuardians, Angels, Rangers +1 · 2006-2017.246/.346/.475, 267 HR, 744 RBI74
  24. 24Yandy DiazGuardians, Rays · 2017-2025.290/.372/.442, 100 HR, 424 RBI74
  25. 25Bruce BochteGuardians, Mariners, Athletics +1 · 1974-1986.282/.360/.396, 100 HR, 658 RBI73

2BSecond basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Nap LajoieGuardians, Phillies, Athletics · 1896-1916.338/.380/.466, 82 HR, 1,599 RBI99
  2. 2Jeff KentGuardians, Giants, Dodgers +3 · 1992-2008.290/.356/.500, 377 HR, 1,518 RBI93
  3. 3Roberto AlomarGuardians, Blue Jays, Padres +4 · 1988-2004.300/.371/.443, 210 HR, 1,134 RBI90
  4. 4Joe GordonGuardians, Yankees · 1938-1950.268/.357/.466, 253 HR, 975 RBI88
  5. 5Brandon PhillipsGuardians, Reds, Braves +2 · 2002-2018.275/.320/.420, 211 HR, 951 RBI86
  6. 6Jorge OrtaGuardians, White Sox, Royals +2 · 1972-1987.278/.334/.412, 130 HR, 745 RBI85
  7. 7Bobby AvilaGuardians, Braves, Red Sox +1 · 1949-1959.281/.359/.388, 80 HR, 467 RBI83
  8. 8Snuffy StirnweissGuardians, Yankees, Orioles · 1943-1952.268/.362/.371, 29 HR, 281 RBI82
  9. 9Carlos BaergaGuardians, Mets, Diamondbacks +3 · 1990-2005.291/.332/.423, 134 HR, 774 RBI81
  10. 10Johnny TempleGuardians, Reds, Astros +1 · 1952-1964.284/.363/.351, 22 HR, 395 RBI81
  11. 11Jason KipnisGuardians, Cubs · 2011-2020.260/.333/.416, 126 HR, 545 RBI80
  12. 12Bip RobertsGuardians, Padres, Reds +3 · 1986-1998.294/.358/.380, 30 HR, 352 RBI79
  13. 13Mark GrudzielanekGuardians, Dodgers, Nationals +3 · 1995-2010.289/.332/.393, 90 HR, 640 RBI78
  14. 14Odell HaleGuardians, Giants, Red Sox · 1931-1941.289/.352/.441, 73 HR, 573 RBI78
  15. 15Germany SchaeferGuardians, Tigers, Twins +2 · 1901-1918.259/.319/.322, 9 HR, 301 RBI77
  16. 16Ronnie BelliardGuardians, Brewers, Nationals +3 · 1998-2010.273/.338/.415, 114 HR, 601 RBI77
  17. 17Cesar HernandezGuardians, Phillies, Nationals +1 · 2013-2022.267/.341/.375, 71 HR, 369 RBI76
  18. 18Tony BernazardGuardians, White Sox, Nationals +3 · 1979-1991.262/.339/.387, 75 HR, 391 RBI76
  19. 19Bill HallmanGuardians, Phillies, Dodgers +1 · 1888-1903.271/.324/.343, 14 HR, 666 RBI75
  20. 20Johnny HodappGuardians, Red Sox, White Sox · 1925-1933.311/.350/.425, 28 HR, 429 RBI75
  21. 21Manny TrilloGuardians, Cubs, Phillies +4 · 1973-1989.263/.316/.345, 61 HR, 571 RBI75
  22. 22Aaron WardGuardians, Yankees, White Sox · 1917-1928.268/.335/.383, 50 HR, 447 RBI74
  23. 23Jerry BrowneGuardians, Rangers, Athletics +1 · 1986-1995.271/.351/.351, 23 HR, 288 RBI74
  24. 24Joey CoraGuardians, Mariners, White Sox +1 · 1987-1998.277/.348/.369, 30 HR, 294 RBI74
  25. 25Bill WambsganssGuardians, Red Sox, Athletics · 1914-1926.259/.328/.327, 7 HR, 520 RBI73

Advertisement

3BThird basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Jose RamirezGuardians · 2013-2025.279/.353/.504, 285 HR, 949 RBI99
  2. 2Josh DonaldsonGuardians, Blue Jays, Athletics +4 · 2010-2023.261/.358/.489, 279 HR, 816 RBI93
  3. 3Graig NettlesGuardians, Yankees, Padres +3 · 1967-1988.248/.329/.421, 390 HR, 1,314 RBI90
  4. 4Al RosenGuardians · 1947-1956.285/.384/.495, 192 HR, 717 RBI88
  5. 5Toby HarrahGuardians, Rangers, Yankees · 1969-1986.264/.365/.395, 195 HR, 918 RBI86
  6. 6Buddy BellGuardians, Rangers, Reds +1 · 1972-1989.279/.341/.406, 201 HR, 1,106 RBI85
  7. 7Matt WilliamsGuardians, Giants, Diamondbacks · 1987-2003.268/.317/.489, 378 HR, 1,218 RBI83
  8. 8Ken KeltnerGuardians, Red Sox · 1937-1950.276/.338/.441, 163 HR, 852 RBI82
  9. 9Larry GardnerGuardians, Red Sox, Athletics · 1908-1924.289/.355/.384, 27 HR, 934 RBI81
  10. 10Ray BooneGuardians, Tigers, White Sox +3 · 1948-1960.275/.361/.429, 151 HR, 737 RBI81
  11. 11Bill BradleyGuardians, Cubs · 1899-1910.274/.320/.376, 34 HR, 540 RBI80
  12. 12Travis FrymanGuardians, Tigers · 1990-2002.274/.336/.443, 223 HR, 1,022 RBI79
  13. 13Kevin SeitzerGuardians, Royals, Brewers +1 · 1986-1997.295/.375/.404, 74 HR, 613 RBI78
  14. 14Mark ReynoldsGuardians, Diamondbacks, Rockies +5 · 2007-2019.236/.328/.453, 298 HR, 871 RBI78
  15. 15Bill MeltonGuardians, White Sox, Angels · 1968-1977.253/.337/.419, 160 HR, 591 RBI77
  16. 16Willie JonesGuardians, Phillies, Reds · 1947-1961.258/.343/.410, 190 HR, 812 RBI77
  17. 17Brook JacobyGuardians, Athletics, Braves · 1981-1992.270/.334/.405, 120 HR, 545 RBI76
  18. 18Willie KammGuardians, White Sox · 1923-1935.281/.372/.384, 29 HR, 826 RBI76
  19. 19Casey BlakeGuardians, Dodgers, Twins +2 · 1999-2011.264/.336/.442, 167 HR, 616 RBI75
  20. 20Dave HollinsGuardians, Phillies, Angels +4 · 1990-2002.260/.358/.420, 112 HR, 482 RBI75
  21. 21Max AlvisGuardians, Brewers · 1962-1970.247/.302/.390, 111 HR, 373 RBI75
  22. 22Randy JacksonGuardians, Cubs, Dodgers · 1950-1959.261/.320/.421, 103 HR, 415 RBI74
  23. 23Rich RollinsGuardians, Twins, Brewers · 1961-1970.269/.328/.388, 77 HR, 399 RBI74
  24. 24Russell BranyanGuardians, Brewers, Mariners +7 · 1998-2011.232/.329/.485, 194 HR, 467 RBI74
  25. 25Aaron BooneGuardians, Reds, Nationals +3 · 1997-2009.263/.326/.425, 126 HR, 555 RBI73

SSShortstops

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Lou BoudreauGuardians, Red Sox · 1938-1952.295/.380/.415, 68 HR, 789 RBI99
  2. 2Hanley RamirezGuardians, Marlins, Red Sox +1 · 2005-2019.289/.360/.486, 271 HR, 917 RBI93
  3. 3Julio FrancoGuardians, Rangers, Braves +5 · 1982-2007.298/.365/.417, 173 HR, 1,194 RBI90
  4. 4Joe SewellGuardians, Yankees · 1920-1933.312/.391/.413, 49 HR, 1,055 RBI88
  5. 5Francisco LindorGuardians, Mets · 2015-2025.273/.342/.475, 279 HR, 856 RBI86
  6. 6Jay BellGuardians, Pirates, Diamondbacks +2 · 1986-2003.265/.343/.416, 195 HR, 860 RBI85
  7. 7Tony FernandezGuardians, Blue Jays, Padres +4 · 1983-2001.288/.347/.399, 94 HR, 844 RBI83
  8. 8Ray ChapmanGuardians · 1912-1920.278/.358/.377, 17 HR, 364 RBI82
  9. 9Asdrubal CabreraGuardians, Mets, Rays +5 · 2007-2021.266/.329/.423, 195 HR, 869 RBI81
  10. 10Jhonny PeraltaGuardians, Tigers, Cardinals · 2003-2017.267/.329/.423, 202 HR, 873 RBI81
  11. 11Leo CardenasGuardians, Reds, Twins +2 · 1960-1975.257/.311/.367, 118 HR, 689 RBI80
  12. 12Woodie HeldGuardians, Athletics, Rangers +4 · 1954-1969.240/.331/.421, 179 HR, 559 RBI79
  13. 13Roger PeckinpaughGuardians, Yankees, Twins +1 · 1910-1927.259/.336/.335, 48 HR, 740 RBI78
  14. 14Terry TurnerGuardians, Athletics, Pirates · 1901-1919.253/.308/.318, 8 HR, 528 RBI78
  15. 15Shawon DunstonGuardians, Cubs, Giants +3 · 1985-2002.269/.296/.416, 150 HR, 668 RBI77
  16. 16Zoilo VersallesGuardians, Twins, Dodgers +2 · 1959-1971.242/.290/.367, 95 HR, 471 RBI77
  17. 17Juan UribeGuardians, White Sox, Dodgers +4 · 2001-2016.255/.301/.418, 199 HR, 816 RBI76
  18. 18Omar VizquelGuardians, Mariners, Giants +3 · 1989-2012.272/.336/.352, 80 HR, 951 RBI76
  19. 19Granny HamnerGuardians, Phillies, Athletics · 1944-1962.262/.303/.383, 104 HR, 708 RBI75
  20. 20Jose HernandezGuardians, Cubs, Brewers +6 · 1991-2006.252/.312/.418, 168 HR, 603 RBI75
  21. 21Lyn LaryGuardians, Yankees, Orioles +4 · 1929-1940.269/.369/.372, 38 HR, 526 RBI75
  22. 22Brad MillerGuardians, Mariners, Rays +4 · 2013-2023.236/.314/.416, 123 HR, 405 RBI74
  23. 23Chico CarrasquelGuardians, White Sox, Orioles +1 · 1950-1959.258/.333/.342, 55 HR, 474 RBI74
  24. 24Orlando CabreraGuardians, Nationals, Angels +6 · 1997-2011.272/.317/.390, 123 HR, 854 RBI74
  25. 25Amed RosarioGuardians, Mets, Rays +4 · 2017-2025.273/.308/.400, 69 HR, 389 RBI73

OFOutfielders

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Tris SpeakerGuardians, Red Sox, Twins +1 · 1907-1928.345/.428/.500, 117 HR, 1,529 RBI99
  2. 2Frank RobinsonGuardians, Reds, Orioles +2 · 1956-1976.294/.389/.537, 586 HR, 1,812 RBI97
  3. 3Manny RamirezGuardians, Red Sox, Dodgers +2 · 1993-2011.312/.411/.585, 555 HR, 1,831 RBI95
  4. 4Dave WinfieldGuardians, Yankees, Padres +3 · 1973-1995.283/.353/.475, 465 HR, 1,833 RBI93
  5. 5Ralph KinerGuardians, Pirates, Cubs · 1946-1955.279/.398/.548, 369 HR, 1,015 RBI92
  6. 6Shoeless Joe JacksonGuardians, White Sox, Athletics · 1908-1920.356/.423/.517, 54 HR, 785 RBI91
  7. 7Earl AverillGuardians, Tigers, Braves · 1929-1941.318/.395/.534, 238 HR, 1,164 RBI90
  8. 8Elmer FlickGuardians, Phillies, Athletics · 1898-1910.313/.389/.445, 48 HR, 756 RBI89
  9. 9Minnie MiñosoGuardians, White Sox, Rangers +1 · 1949-1980.298/.389/.459, 186 HR, 1,023 RBI89
  10. 10Rocky ColavitoGuardians, Tigers, Athletics +3 · 1955-1968.266/.359/.489, 374 HR, 1,159 RBI88
  11. 11Brian GilesGuardians, Padres, Pirates · 1995-2009.291/.400/.502, 287 HR, 1,078 RBI87
  12. 12Larry DobyGuardians, White Sox, Tigers · 1947-1959.283/.386/.490, 253 HR, 970 RBI87
  13. 13Albert BelleGuardians, White Sox, Orioles · 1989-2000.295/.369/.564, 381 HR, 1,239 RBI86
  14. 14Bobby BondsGuardians, Giants, Angels +5 · 1968-1981.268/.353/.471, 332 HR, 1,024 RBI86
  15. 15Juan GonzalezGuardians, Rangers, Tigers +1 · 1989-2005.295/.343/.561, 434 HR, 1,404 RBI85
  16. 16Vada PinsonGuardians, Reds, Angels +2 · 1958-1975.286/.327/.442, 256 HR, 1,169 RBI85
  17. 17Ellis BurksGuardians, Red Sox, Rockies +2 · 1987-2004.291/.363/.510, 352 HR, 1,206 RBI84
  18. 18Roger MarisGuardians, Yankees, Cardinals +1 · 1957-1968.260/.345/.476, 275 HR, 851 RBI84
  19. 19David JusticeGuardians, Braves, Yankees +1 · 1989-2002.279/.378/.500, 305 HR, 1,017 RBI83
  20. 20Sam RiceGuardians, Twins · 1915-1934.322/.374/.427, 34 HR, 1,078 RBI83
  21. 21Willie HortonGuardians, Tigers, Mariners +3 · 1963-1980.273/.332/.457, 325 HR, 1,163 RBI83
  22. 22Jeff HeathGuardians, Orioles, Braves +1 · 1936-1949.293/.370/.509, 194 HR, 887 RBI82
  23. 23Rico CartyGuardians, Braves, Blue Jays +3 · 1963-1979.299/.369/.464, 204 HR, 890 RBI82
  24. 24Vic WertzGuardians, Tigers, Red Sox +2 · 1947-1963.277/.364/.469, 266 HR, 1,178 RBI82
  25. 25George HendrickGuardians, Cardinals, Angels +3 · 1971-1988.278/.329/.446, 267 HR, 1,111 RBI81

DHDesignated hitters

Top 11 of 11
  1. 1Harold BainesGuardians, White Sox, Orioles +2 · 1980-2001.289/.356/.465, 384 HR, 1,628 RBI99
  2. 2Edwin EncarnacionGuardians, Blue Jays, Reds +3 · 2005-2020.260/.350/.496, 424 HR, 1,261 RBI93
  3. 3Victor MartinezGuardians, Tigers, Red Sox · 2002-2018.295/.360/.455, 246 HR, 1,178 RBI90
  4. 4Andre ThorntonGuardians, Cubs, Nationals · 1973-1987.254/.360/.452, 253 HR, 895 RBI88
  5. 5Travis HafnerGuardians, Yankees, Rangers · 2002-2013.273/.376/.498, 213 HR, 731 RBI86
  6. 6Cliff JohnsonGuardians, Blue Jays, Astros +4 · 1972-1986.258/.355/.459, 196 HR, 699 RBI85
  7. 7Ken PhelpsGuardians, Mariners, Yankees +3 · 1980-1990.239/.374/.480, 123 HR, 313 RBI83
  8. 8Reggie JeffersonGuardians, Red Sox, Mariners +1 · 1991-1999.300/.349/.474, 72 HR, 300 RBI82
  9. 9Franmil ReyesGuardians, Padres, Cubs +1 · 2018-2023.249/.310/.464, 108 HR, 285 RBI81
  10. 10Josh PhelpsGuardians, Blue Jays, Pirates +3 · 2000-2008.273/.343/.472, 64 HR, 244 RBI81
  11. 11Sam HornGuardians, Orioles, Red Sox +1 · 1987-1995.240/.328/.468, 62 HR, 179 RBI80

SPStarting pitchers

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Cy YoungGuardians, CLV, Red Sox +2 · 1890-1911511-315, 2.63 ERA, 2,803 K99
  2. 2Bob FellerGuardians · 1936-1956266-162, 3.25 ERA, 2,581 K97
  3. 3Gaylord PerryGuardians, Giants, Rangers +5 · 1962-1983314-265, 3.11 ERA, 3,534 K95
  4. 4Steve CarltonGuardians, Phillies, Cardinals +3 · 1965-1988329-244, 3.22 ERA, 4,136 K93
  5. 5Bert BlylevenGuardians, Twins, Pirates +2 · 1970-1992287-250, 3.31 ERA, 3,701 K92
  6. 6Phil NiekroGuardians, Braves, Yankees +1 · 1964-1987318-274, 3.35 ERA, 3,342 K91
  7. 7Early WynnGuardians, Twins, White Sox · 1939-1963300-244, 3.54 ERA, 2,334 K90
  8. 8CC SabathiaGuardians, Yankees, Brewers · 2001-2019251-161, 3.74 ERA, 3,093 K89
  9. 9Hal NewhouserGuardians, Tigers · 1939-1955207-150, 3.06 ERA, 1,796 K89
  10. 10Bob LemonGuardians · 1941-1958207-128, 3.23 ERA, 1,277 K88
  11. 11Mel HarderGuardians · 1928-1947223-186, 3.80 ERA, 1,160 K87
  12. 12Tommy JohnGuardians, White Sox, Yankees +3 · 1963-1989288-231, 3.34 ERA, 2,245 K87
  13. 13Chuck FinleyGuardians, Angels, Cardinals · 1986-2002200-173, 3.85 ERA, 2,610 K86
  14. 14Stan CoveleskiGuardians, Twins, Yankees +1 · 1912-1928215-142, 2.89 ERA, 981 K86
  15. 15Jack MorrisGuardians, Tigers, Blue Jays +1 · 1977-1994254-186, 3.90 ERA, 2,478 K85
  16. 16Orel HershiserGuardians, Dodgers, Giants +1 · 1983-2000204-150, 3.48 ERA, 2,014 K85
  17. 17Bartolo ColonGuardians, Mets, Angels +8 · 1997-2018247-188, 4.12 ERA, 2,535 K84
  18. 18Dennis MartinezGuardians, Orioles, Nationals +2 · 1976-1998245-193, 3.70 ERA, 2,149 K84
  19. 19Cliff LeeGuardians, Phillies, Rangers +1 · 2002-2014143-91, 3.52 ERA, 1,824 K83
  20. 20Dwight GoodenGuardians, Mets, Yankees +2 · 1984-2000194-112, 3.51 ERA, 2,293 K83
  21. 21Wes FerrellGuardians, Red Sox, Twins +3 · 1927-1941193-128, 4.04 ERA, 985 K83
  22. 22Allie ReynoldsGuardians, Yankees · 1942-1954182-107, 3.30 ERA, 1,423 K82
  23. 23Sad Sam JonesGuardians, Yankees, Red Sox +3 · 1914-1935229-217, 3.84 ERA, 1,223 K82
  24. 24Thornton LeeGuardians, White Sox, Giants · 1933-1948117-124, 3.56 ERA, 937 K82
  25. 25Derek LoweGuardians, Red Sox, Dodgers +4 · 1997-2013176-157, 4.03 ERA, 1,722 K81

RPRelief pitchers

Top 25 of 60
  1. 1Dennis EckersleyGuardians, Athletics, Red Sox +2 · 1975-1998390 SV, 3.50 ERA, 2,401 K99
  2. 2Hoyt WilhelmGuardians, White Sox, Giants +6 · 1952-1972227 SV, 2.52 ERA, 1,610 K96
  3. 3Roberto HernandezGuardians, White Sox, Rays +7 · 1991-2007326 SV, 3.45 ERA, 945 K93
  4. 4Doug JonesGuardians, Astros, Brewers +4 · 1982-2000303 SV, 3.30 ERA, 909 K92
  5. 5Greg SwindellGuardians, Diamondbacks, Twins +3 · 1986-20027 SV, 3.86 ERA, 1,542 K90
  6. 6Al BentonGuardians, Tigers, Athletics +1 · 1934-195266 SV, 3.66 ERA, 697 K89
  7. 7Bob WickmanGuardians, Brewers, Yankees +2 · 1992-2007267 SV, 3.57 ERA, 785 K88
  8. 8Kerry WoodGuardians, Cubs, Yankees · 1998-201263 SV, 3.67 ERA, 1,582 K87
  9. 9Jesse OroscoGuardians, Mets, Orioles +6 · 1979-2003144 SV, 3.16 ERA, 1,179 K86
  10. 10Jose MesaGuardians, Phillies, Mariners +5 · 1987-2007321 SV, 4.36 ERA, 1,038 K85
  11. 11Lloyd BrownGuardians, Twins, Red Sox +3 · 1925-194021 SV, 4.20 ERA, 510 K85
  12. 12Michael JacksonGuardians, Mariners, Giants +5 · 1986-2004142 SV, 3.42 ERA, 1,006 K84
  13. 13Don McMahonGuardians, Braves, Giants +4 · 1957-1974153 SV, 2.96 ERA, 1,003 K83
  14. 14Don MossiGuardians, Tigers, Athletics +1 · 1954-196550 SV, 3.43 ERA, 932 K83
  15. 15Clint BrownGuardians, White Sox · 1928-194264 SV, 4.26 ERA, 410 K82
  16. 16Jeff ShawGuardians, Dodgers, Reds +2 · 1990-2001203 SV, 3.54 ERA, 545 K82
  17. 17Jack RussellGuardians, Red Sox, Twins +3 · 1926-194038 SV, 4.46 ERA, 418 K81
  18. 18Stan WilliamsGuardians, Dodgers, Twins +3 · 1958-197243 SV, 3.48 ERA, 1,305 K81
  19. 19Terry MulhollandGuardians, Phillies, Cubs +8 · 1986-20065 SV, 4.41 ERA, 1,325 K81
  20. 20Dave BurbaGuardians, Giants, Reds +3 · 1990-20043 SV, 4.49 ERA, 1,398 K80
  21. 21Hank AguirreGuardians, Tigers, Cubs +1 · 1955-197033 SV, 3.24 ERA, 856 K80
  22. 22Eddie FisherGuardians, White Sox, Angels +3 · 1959-197381 SV, 3.41 ERA, 812 K79
  23. 23Jeff RussellGuardians, Rangers, Red Sox +2 · 1983-1996186 SV, 3.75 ERA, 693 K79
  24. 24Steve FarrGuardians, Royals, Yankees +1 · 1984-1994132 SV, 3.25 ERA, 668 K79
  25. 25Emmanuel ClaseGuardians, Rangers · 2019-2025182 SV, 1.88 ERA, 349 K78

About this pool

Who is the highest rated player in the All-time Guardians pool?
Lance Parrish (catcher, Guardians, Tigers +5) at 99, from .252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI.
Who is the best catcher to draft from the All-time Guardians pool?
Lance Parrish is rated 99: .252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI.
Who is the best first baseman to draft from the All-time Guardians pool?
Jim Thome is rated 99: .276/.402/.554, 612 HR, 1,699 RBI.
Who is the best second baseman to draft from the All-time Guardians pool?
Nap Lajoie is rated 99: .338/.380/.466, 82 HR, 1,599 RBI.
Who is the best third baseman to draft from the All-time Guardians pool?
Jose Ramirez is rated 99: .279/.353/.504, 285 HR, 949 RBI.
How many players can be drafted from the All-time Guardians pool?
426 players, the best at each position deep enough for eight teams to fill every lineup slot about three times over. Everyone who played for the Cleveland Guardians franchise, in every city it has called home.

Other MLB pools