Skip to main content
parlae.ioBeta
Sign in

All-time Pirates MLB draft pool

Everyone who played for the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, in every city it has called home. 418 players you can draft, each rated 40 to 99 from real stats. Ratings updated October 10, 2026.

Draft from this pool How the ratings work
Tenace99Greenberg99Herman99Elliott99Wagner99Bonds99Page99Blyleven99Gossage99Stargell97Vance97Wood96

CCatchers

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Gene TenacePirates, Athletics, Padres +1 · 1969-1983.241/.388/.429, 201 HR, 674 RBI99
  2. 2Walker CooperPirates, Cardinals, Braves +3 · 1940-1957.285/.332/.464, 173 HR, 812 RBI93
  3. 3Lance ParrishPirates, Tigers, Angels +4 · 1977-1995.252/.313/.440, 324 HR, 1,070 RBI90
  4. 4Smoky BurgessPirates, Reds, Phillies +2 · 1949-1967.295/.362/.446, 126 HR, 673 RBI88
  5. 5Jason KendallPirates, Athletics, Brewers +2 · 1996-2010.288/.366/.378, 75 HR, 744 RBI86
  6. 6Virgil DavisPirates, Phillies, Cardinals +1 · 1928-1945.308/.369/.430, 77 HR, 647 RBI85
  7. 7Russell MartinPirates, Dodgers, Blue Jays +1 · 2006-2019.248/.349/.397, 191 HR, 771 RBI83
  8. 8Yasmani GrandalPirates, Dodgers, White Sox +2 · 2012-2024.236/.345/.424, 194 HR, 592 RBI82
  9. 9Benito SantiagoPirates, Padres, Giants +6 · 1986-2005.263/.307/.415, 217 HR, 920 RBI81
  10. 10Manny SanguillenPirates, Athletics · 1967-1980.296/.326/.398, 65 HR, 585 RBI81
  11. 11Del CrandallPirates, Braves, Giants +1 · 1949-1966.254/.312/.404, 179 HR, 657 RBI80
  12. 12Babe PhelpsPirates, Dodgers, Cubs +1 · 1931-1942.310/.362/.472, 54 HR, 345 RBI79
  13. 13George MillerPirates, Cardinals, LOU · 1887-1896.276/.343/.359, 31 HR, 518 RBI78
  14. 14Tony PeñaPirates, Red Sox, Cardinals +3 · 1980-1997.260/.309/.364, 107 HR, 708 RBI78
  15. 15Don SlaughtPirates, Rangers, Royals +4 · 1982-1997.283/.338/.412, 77 HR, 476 RBI77
  16. 16Duke FarrellPirates, WAS, Dodgers +3 · 1888-1905.273/.332/.374, 38 HR, 722 RBI77
  17. 17Charles ZimmerPirates, CLV, LOU +2 · 1884-1903.272/.342/.372, 26 HR, 598 RBI76
  18. 18Phil MasiPirates, Braves, White Sox · 1939-1952.264/.344/.370, 47 HR, 417 RBI76
  19. 19Brian HarperPirates, Twins, Brewers +4 · 1979-1995.295/.329/.419, 63 HR, 428 RBI75
  20. 20Earl SmithPirates, Giants, Braves +1 · 1919-1930.303/.374/.432, 46 HR, 355 RBI75
  21. 21Jim PagliaroniPirates, Red Sox, Athletics +1 · 1955-1969.252/.344/.407, 90 HR, 326 RBI75
  22. 22Heinie PeitzPirates, Reds, Cardinals · 1892-1913.271/.342/.361, 16 HR, 560 RBI74
  23. 23John JasoPirates, Rays, Athletics +1 · 2008-2017.258/.356/.407, 55 HR, 281 RBI74
  24. 24Ryan DoumitPirates, Twins, Braves · 2005-2014.264/.324/.432, 104 HR, 413 RBI74
  25. 25Al LopezPirates, Dodgers, Braves +1 · 1928-1947.261/.326/.337, 51 HR, 652 RBI73

1BFirst basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Hank GreenbergPirates, Tigers · 1930-1947.313/.412/.605, 331 HR, 1,276 RBI99
  2. 2Jake BeckleyPirates, Reds, Cardinals +1 · 1888-1907.307/.360/.430, 78 HR, 1,458 RBI93
  3. 3Mickey VernonPirates, Twins, Guardians +2 · 1939-1960.286/.359/.428, 172 HR, 1,311 RBI90
  4. 4Derrek LeePirates, Cubs, Marlins +3 · 1997-2011.281/.365/.495, 331 HR, 1,078 RBI88
  5. 5Ted KluszewskiPirates, Reds, White Sox +1 · 1947-1961.298/.353/.498, 279 HR, 1,028 RBI86
  6. 6Harry DavisPirates, Athletics, Giants +3 · 1895-1917.277/.335/.408, 75 HR, 951 RBI85
  7. 7Ed KonetchyPirates, Cardinals, Braves +2 · 1907-1921.278/.345/.396, 64 HR, 899 RBI83
  8. 8Justin MorneauPirates, Twins, Rockies +1 · 2003-2016.281/.348/.481, 247 HR, 985 RBI82
  9. 9Carlos SantanaPirates, Guardians, Royals +5 · 2010-2025.241/.352/.425, 335 HR, 1,136 RBI81
  10. 10Jason ThompsonPirates, Tigers, Angels +1 · 1976-1986.261/.366/.438, 208 HR, 782 RBI81
  11. 11Elbie FletcherPirates, Braves · 1934-1949.271/.384/.390, 79 HR, 616 RBI80
  12. 12Ripper CollinsPirates, Cardinals, Cubs · 1931-1941.296/.360/.492, 135 HR, 659 RBI79
  13. 13George KellyPirates, Giants, Reds +2 · 1915-1932.297/.342/.452, 148 HR, 1,020 RBI78
  14. 14Stuffy McInnisPirates, Athletics, Red Sox +3 · 1909-1927.307/.343/.381, 20 HR, 1,063 RBI78
  15. 15Adam LaRochePirates, Nationals, Braves +3 · 2004-2015.260/.336/.462, 255 HR, 882 RBI77
  16. 16Gus SuhrPirates, Phillies · 1930-1940.279/.368/.428, 84 HR, 818 RBI77
  17. 17Donn ClendenonPirates, Mets, Cardinals +1 · 1961-1972.274/.328/.442, 159 HR, 682 RBI76
  18. 18Sean CaseyPirates, Reds, Tigers +2 · 1997-2008.302/.367/.447, 130 HR, 735 RBI76
  19. 19Dick StuartPirates, Red Sox, Phillies +3 · 1958-1969.264/.316/.489, 228 HR, 743 RBI75
  20. 20Joe HarrisPirates, Red Sox, Twins +3 · 1914-1928.317/.404/.472, 47 HR, 517 RBI75
  21. 21Willie MontanezPirates, Phillies, Mets +6 · 1966-1982.275/.327/.402, 139 HR, 802 RBI75
  22. 22Charlie GrimmPirates, Cubs, Cardinals +1 · 1916-1936.290/.341/.397, 79 HR, 1,078 RBI74
  23. 23Josh BellPirates, Nationals, Marlins +3 · 2016-2025.256/.341/.443, 193 HR, 676 RBI74
  24. 24Vic SaierPirates, Cubs · 1911-1919.263/.351/.409, 55 HR, 395 RBI74
  25. 25Dots MillerPirates, Cardinals, Phillies · 1909-1921.263/.314/.357, 32 HR, 715 RBI73

2BSecond basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Billy HermanPirates, Cubs, Dodgers +1 · 1931-1947.304/.367/.407, 47 HR, 839 RBI99
  2. 2George GranthamPirates, Cubs, Reds +1 · 1922-1934.302/.392/.461, 105 HR, 712 RBI93
  3. 3Jimmy WilliamsPirates, Yankees, Orioles · 1899-1909.275/.337/.396, 49 HR, 796 RBI90
  4. 4Willie RandolphPirates, Yankees, Dodgers +3 · 1975-1992.276/.373/.351, 54 HR, 687 RBI88
  5. 5Claude RitcheyPirates, LOU, Braves +1 · 1897-1909.273/.348/.342, 18 HR, 675 RBI86
  6. 6Phil GarnerPirates, Astros, Athletics +2 · 1973-1988.260/.323/.389, 109 HR, 738 RBI85
  7. 7Neil WalkerPirates, Mets, Marlins +3 · 2009-2020.267/.338/.426, 149 HR, 609 RBI83
  8. 8Johnny RayPirates, Angels · 1981-1990.290/.333/.391, 53 HR, 594 RBI82
  9. 9Bill MazeroskiPirates · 1956-1972.260/.299/.367, 138 HR, 853 RBI81
  10. 10Fred DunlapPirates, CBL, SLM +1 · 1880-1890.277/.326/.378, 28 HR, 362 RBI81
  11. 11Dave CashPirates, Phillies, Nationals +1 · 1969-1980.283/.334/.358, 21 HR, 426 RBI80
  12. 12Bobby LowePirates, Braves, Tigers +1 · 1890-1907.273/.325/.360, 71 HR, 989 RBI79
  13. 13Freddy SanchezPirates, Giants, Red Sox · 2002-2011.297/.335/.413, 48 HR, 371 RBI78
  14. 14Gene DeMontrevillePirates, WAS, Braves +5 · 1894-1904.303/.340/.373, 17 HR, 497 RBI78
  15. 15Frankie GustinePirates, Cubs, Orioles · 1939-1950.265/.322/.359, 38 HR, 480 RBI77
  16. 16George CutshawPirates, Dodgers, Tigers · 1912-1923.265/.305/.344, 25 HR, 653 RBI77
  17. 17Ed AbbaticchioPirates, Braves, Phillies · 1897-1910.254/.325/.325, 11 HR, 324 RBI76
  18. 18Josh HarrisonPirates, Nationals, White Sox +3 · 2011-2023.270/.316/.396, 73 HR, 388 RBI76
  19. 19Adam FrazierPirates, Royals, Mariners +2 · 2016-2025.264/.326/.383, 67 HR, 383 RBI75
  20. 20Jim VioxPirates · 1912-1916.273/.361/.358, 7 HR, 191 RBI75
  21. 21Wally BackmanPirates, Mets, Phillies +2 · 1980-1993.275/.349/.339, 10 HR, 240 RBI75
  22. 22Henry ReitzPirates, BLO, WAS · 1893-1899.292/.363/.391, 11 HR, 463 RBI74
  23. 23Jimmy BrownPirates, Cardinals · 1937-1946.279/.326/.352, 9 HR, 319 RBI74
  24. 24Otto KnabePirates, Phillies, Cubs · 1905-1916.249/.327/.314, 5 HR, 298 RBI74
  25. 25Don GutteridgePirates, Orioles, Cardinals +1 · 1936-1948.256/.308/.362, 39 HR, 391 RBI73

Advertisement

3BThird basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Bob ElliottPirates, Braves, Giants +2 · 1939-1953.289/.375/.440, 170 HR, 1,195 RBI99
  2. 2Bobby BonillaPirates, Mets, Orioles +5 · 1986-2001.279/.358/.472, 287 HR, 1,173 RBI93
  3. 3Aramis RamirezPirates, Cubs, Brewers · 1998-2015.283/.341/.492, 386 HR, 1,417 RBI90
  4. 4Bill MadlockPirates, Cubs, Giants +3 · 1973-1987.305/.365/.442, 163 HR, 860 RBI88
  5. 5Pie TraynorPirates · 1920-1937.320/.362/.435, 58 HR, 1,273 RBI86
  6. 6Heinie GrohPirates, Reds, Giants · 1912-1927.292/.373/.384, 26 HR, 566 RBI85
  7. 7Richie HebnerPirates, Phillies, Tigers +2 · 1968-1985.276/.352/.438, 203 HR, 890 RBI83
  8. 8Deacon WhitePirates, BUF, DTN +3 · 1876-1889.307/.341/.388, 18 HR, 709 RBI82
  9. 9Bob BaileyPirates, Nationals, Dodgers +2 · 1962-1978.257/.347/.403, 189 HR, 773 RBI81
  10. 10Freddie LindstromPirates, Giants, Cubs +1 · 1924-1936.311/.351/.449, 103 HR, 779 RBI81
  11. 11Hans LobertPirates, Reds, Phillies +2 · 1903-1917.274/.337/.366, 32 HR, 482 RBI80
  12. 12Todd FrazierPirates, Reds, Mets +3 · 2011-2021.241/.318/.445, 218 HR, 640 RBI79
  13. 13Cookie LavagettoPirates, Dodgers · 1934-1947.269/.360/.377, 40 HR, 486 RBI78
  14. 14Don HoakPirates, Reds, Dodgers +2 · 1954-1964.265/.345/.396, 89 HR, 498 RBI78
  15. 15David FreesePirates, Cardinals, Angels +1 · 2009-2019.277/.351/.423, 113 HR, 535 RBI77
  16. 16Tom BurnsPirates, Cubs · 1880-1892.266/.305/.365, 39 HR, 683 RBI77
  17. 17Joe RandaPirates, Royals, Tigers +2 · 1995-2006.284/.339/.426, 123 HR, 739 RBI76
  18. 18Ken OberkfellPirates, Cardinals, Braves +3 · 1977-1992.278/.351/.362, 29 HR, 446 RBI76
  19. 19Bobby ByrnePirates, Cardinals, Phillies +1 · 1907-1917.254/.324/.323, 10 HR, 329 RBI75
  20. 20Jeff KingPirates, Royals · 1989-1999.256/.324/.425, 154 HR, 709 RBI75
  21. 21Ty WiggintonPirates, Mets, Orioles +5 · 2002-2013.261/.323/.435, 169 HR, 594 RBI75
  22. 22Bob DillingerPirates, Orioles, White Sox +1 · 1946-1951.306/.363/.391, 10 HR, 213 RBI74
  23. 23Pedro AlvarezPirates, Orioles · 2010-2018.236/.310/.447, 162 HR, 472 RBI74
  24. 24Wid ConroyPirates, Yankees, Twins +1 · 1901-1911.248/.301/.329, 22 HR, 452 RBI74
  25. 25Charlie HayesPirates, Phillies, Rockies +4 · 1988-2001.262/.316/.398, 144 HR, 740 RBI73

SSShortstops

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Honus WagnerPirates, LOU · 1897-1917.328/.391/.467, 101 HR, 1,733 RBI99
  2. 2Arky VaughanPirates, Dodgers · 1932-1948.318/.406/.453, 96 HR, 926 RBI93
  3. 3Joe CroninPirates, Red Sox, Twins · 1926-1945.301/.390/.468, 170 HR, 1,424 RBI90
  4. 4Jim FregosiPirates, Angels, Rangers +1 · 1961-1978.265/.338/.398, 151 HR, 706 RBI88
  5. 5Jay BellPirates, Diamondbacks, Royals +2 · 1986-2003.265/.343/.416, 195 HR, 860 RBI86
  6. 6Jack GlasscockPirates, CBL, IND +5 · 1879-1895.287/.335/.369, 25 HR, 827 RBI85
  7. 7Dick BartellPirates, Giants, Phillies +2 · 1927-1946.284/.355/.391, 79 HR, 710 RBI83
  8. 8Dick GroatPirates, Cardinals, Phillies +1 · 1952-1967.286/.330/.366, 39 HR, 707 RBI82
  9. 9Jack RowePirates, BUF, DTN · 1879-1889.291/.323/.399, 26 HR, 568 RBI81
  10. 10Maury WillsPirates, Dodgers, Nationals · 1959-1972.281/.330/.331, 20 HR, 458 RBI81
  11. 11Rabbit MaranvillePirates, Braves, Cardinals +2 · 1912-1935.258/.318/.340, 28 HR, 884 RBI80
  12. 12Glenn WrightPirates, Dodgers, White Sox · 1924-1935.294/.328/.447, 94 HR, 723 RBI79
  13. 13Johnny LoganPirates, Braves · 1951-1963.268/.330/.378, 93 HR, 547 RBI78
  14. 14Terry TurnerPirates, Guardians, Athletics · 1901-1919.253/.308/.318, 8 HR, 528 RBI78
  15. 15Jose HernandezPirates, Cubs, Brewers +6 · 1991-2006.252/.312/.418, 168 HR, 603 RBI77
  16. 16Shawon DunstonPirates, Cubs, Giants +3 · 1985-2002.269/.296/.416, 150 HR, 668 RBI77
  17. 17Gene AlleyPirates · 1963-1973.254/.310/.354, 55 HR, 342 RBI76
  18. 18Monte CrossPirates, Athletics, Phillies +2 · 1892-1907.234/.316/.313, 31 HR, 621 RBI76
  19. 19Andre RodgersPirates, Cubs, Giants · 1957-1967.249/.328/.365, 45 HR, 245 RBI75
  20. 20Frank ShugartPirates, Cardinals, LOU +2 · 1891-1901.270/.326/.379, 22 HR, 369 RBI75
  21. 21Jordy MercerPirates, Tigers, Nationals +1 · 2012-2021.256/.315/.386, 66 HR, 308 RBI75
  22. 22Clint BarmesPirates, Rockies, Astros +1 · 2003-2015.245/.294/.379, 89 HR, 415 RBI74
  23. 23Freddie PatekPirates, Royals, Angels · 1968-1981.242/.309/.324, 41 HR, 490 RBI74
  24. 24Otto KruegerPirates, Cardinals, Phillies +1 · 1899-1905.251/.326/.322, 5 HR, 196 RBI74
  25. 25Craig ReynoldsPirates, Astros, Mariners · 1975-1989.256/.291/.345, 42 HR, 377 RBI73

OFOutfielders

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Barry BondsPirates, Giants · 1986-2007.298/.444/.607, 762 HR, 1,996 RBI99
  2. 2Willie StargellPirates · 1962-1982.282/.360/.529, 475 HR, 1,540 RBI97
  3. 3Paul WanerPirates, Braves, Dodgers +1 · 1926-1945.333/.404/.473, 113 HR, 1,309 RBI95
  4. 4Roberto ClementePirates · 1955-1972.317/.359/.475, 240 HR, 1,305 RBI93
  5. 5Ralph KinerPirates, Cubs, Guardians · 1946-1955.279/.398/.548, 369 HR, 1,015 RBI92
  6. 6Dave ParkerPirates, Reds, Athletics +3 · 1973-1991.290/.339/.471, 339 HR, 1,493 RBI91
  7. 7Chuck KleinPirates, Phillies, Cubs · 1928-1944.320/.379/.543, 300 HR, 1,201 RBI90
  8. 8Andrew McCutchenPirates, Phillies, Brewers +2 · 2009-2025.271/.365/.457, 332 HR, 1,152 RBI89
  9. 9Fred ClarkePirates, LOU · 1894-1915.312/.386/.429, 67 HR, 1,015 RBI89
  10. 10Joe KelleyPirates, BLO, Reds +3 · 1891-1908.317/.402/.451, 65 HR, 1,194 RBI88
  11. 11Brian GilesPirates, Padres, Guardians · 1995-2009.291/.400/.502, 287 HR, 1,078 RBI87
  12. 12Moises AlouPirates, Nationals, Cubs +4 · 1990-2008.303/.369/.516, 332 HR, 1,287 RBI87
  13. 13Al OliverPirates, Rangers, Nationals +4 · 1968-1985.303/.344/.451, 219 HR, 1,326 RBI86
  14. 14Kiki CuylerPirates, Cubs, Reds +1 · 1921-1938.321/.386/.474, 128 HR, 1,065 RBI86
  15. 15Heinie ManushPirates, Twins, Tigers +3 · 1923-1939.330/.377/.479, 110 HR, 1,183 RBI85
  16. 16Jose BautistaPirates, Blue Jays, Mets +5 · 2004-2018.247/.361/.475, 344 HR, 975 RBI85
  17. 17Babe HermanPirates, Dodgers, Reds +2 · 1926-1945.324/.383/.532, 181 HR, 997 RBI84
  18. 18Dixie WalkerPirates, Dodgers, White Sox +2 · 1931-1949.306/.383/.437, 105 HR, 1,023 RBI84
  19. 19George Van HaltrenPirates, Giants, Cubs +1 · 1887-1903.315/.384/.414, 55 HR, 878 RBI83
  20. 20Max CareyPirates, Dodgers · 1910-1929.285/.361/.386, 70 HR, 800 RBI83
  21. 21Mike DonlinPirates, Giants, Reds +3 · 1899-1914.333/.386/.468, 51 HR, 543 RBI83
  22. 22Amos OtisPirates, Royals, Mets · 1967-1984.277/.343/.425, 193 HR, 1,007 RBI82
  23. 23Paul HinesPirates, PRO, IND +3 · 1876-1890.301/.342/.415, 56 HR, 720 RBI82
  24. 24Sid GordonPirates, Giants, Braves · 1941-1955.283/.377/.466, 202 HR, 805 RBI82
  25. 25Frank SchultePirates, Cubs, Twins +1 · 1904-1918.270/.332/.395, 92 HR, 792 RBI81

DHDesignated hitters

Top 3 of 3
  1. 1Mitchell PagePirates, Athletics · 1977-1984.266/.346/.429, 72 HR, 259 RBI99
  2. 2Dan VogelbachPirates, Mariners, Mets +2 · 2016-2024.219/.340/.405, 81 HR, 246 RBI93
  3. 3Josh PhelpsPirates, Blue Jays, Rays +3 · 2000-2008.273/.343/.472, 64 HR, 244 RBI90

SPStarting pitchers

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Bert BlylevenPirates, Twins, Guardians +2 · 1970-1992287-250, 3.31 ERA, 3,701 K99
  2. 2Dazzy VancePirates, Dodgers, Cardinals +2 · 1915-1935197-140, 3.24 ERA, 2,045 K97
  3. 3Jim BunningPirates, Tigers, Phillies +1 · 1955-1971224-184, 3.27 ERA, 2,855 K95
  4. 4Pud GalvinPirates, BUF, Cardinals · 1879-1892317-267, 2.81 ERA, 1,665 K93
  5. 5Waite HoytPirates, Yankees, Tigers +4 · 1918-1938237-182, 3.59 ERA, 1,206 K92
  6. 6Burleigh GrimesPirates, Dodgers, Cardinals +4 · 1916-1934270-212, 3.53 ERA, 1,512 K91
  7. 7Vic WillisPirates, Braves, Cardinals · 1898-1910249-205, 2.63 ERA, 1,651 K90
  8. 8Jim McCormickPirates, CBL, Cubs +2 · 1878-1887244-211, 2.48 ERA, 1,543 K89
  9. 9Rube WaddellPirates, Athletics, Orioles +2 · 1897-1910193-143, 2.16 ERA, 2,316 K89
  10. 10Gerrit ColePirates, Yankees, Astros · 2013-2024153-80, 3.18 ERA, 2,251 K88
  11. 11Larry FrenchPirates, Cubs, Dodgers · 1929-1942197-171, 3.44 ERA, 1,187 K87
  12. 12Pink HawleyPirates, Cardinals, Reds +2 · 1892-1901167-179, 3.96 ERA, 868 K87
  13. 13Bob FriendPirates, Mets, Yankees · 1951-1966197-230, 3.58 ERA, 1,734 K86
  14. 14Wilbur CooperPirates, Cubs, Tigers · 1912-1926216-178, 2.89 ERA, 1,252 K86
  15. 15Brickyard KennedyPirates, Dodgers, Giants · 1892-1903187-159, 3.96 ERA, 799 K85
  16. 16Luis TiantPirates, Red Sox, Guardians +3 · 1964-1982229-172, 3.30 ERA, 2,416 K85
  17. 17Claude PasseauPirates, Cubs, Phillies · 1935-1947162-150, 3.32 ERA, 1,104 K84
  18. 18Rick ReuschelPirates, Cubs, Giants +1 · 1972-1991214-191, 3.37 ERA, 2,015 K84
  19. 19Babe AdamsPirates, Cardinals · 1906-1926194-140, 2.76 ERA, 1,036 K83
  20. 20Frank KillenPirates, WAS, Braves +1 · 1892-1900157-127, 3.86 ERA, 687 K83
  21. 21Tim WakefieldPirates, Red Sox · 1992-2011200-180, 4.41 ERA, 2,156 K83
  22. 22Deacon PhillippePirates, LOU · 1899-1911189-109, 2.59 ERA, 929 K82
  23. 23Jouett MeekinPirates, Giants, WAS +2 · 1892-1900143-117, 4.05 ERA, 760 K82
  24. 24Sam McDowellPirates, Guardians, Giants +1 · 1961-1975141-134, 3.17 ERA, 2,453 K82
  25. 25Danny DarwinPirates, Astros, Rangers +5 · 1978-1998171-182, 3.84 ERA, 1,942 K81

RPRelief pitchers

Top 25 of 60
  1. 1Rich GossagePirates, Yankees, Padres +6 · 1972-1994310 SV, 3.01 ERA, 1,502 K99
  2. 2Wilbur WoodPirates, White Sox, Red Sox · 1961-197857 SV, 3.24 ERA, 1,411 K96
  3. 3Bobby ShantzPirates, Athletics, Yankees +4 · 1949-196448 SV, 3.38 ERA, 1,072 K93
  4. 4Roberto HernandezPirates, White Sox, Rays +7 · 1991-2007326 SV, 3.45 ERA, 945 K92
  5. 5Aroldis ChapmanPirates, Reds, Yankees +4 · 2010-2025367 SV, 2.52 ERA, 1,331 K90
  6. 6Kent TekulvePirates, Phillies, Reds · 1974-1989184 SV, 2.85 ERA, 779 K89
  7. 7Billy O'DellPirates, Giants, Orioles +1 · 1954-196748 SV, 3.29 ERA, 1,133 K88
  8. 8Jose MesaPirates, Guardians, Phillies +5 · 1987-2007321 SV, 4.36 ERA, 1,038 K87
  9. 9Clay CarrollPirates, Reds, Braves +2 · 1964-1978143 SV, 2.94 ERA, 681 K86
  10. 10Gene GarberPirates, Braves, Phillies +1 · 1969-1988218 SV, 3.34 ERA, 940 K85
  11. 11Mark MelanconPirates, Giants, Astros +6 · 2009-2022262 SV, 2.94 ERA, 643 K85
  12. 12Joakim SoriaPirates, Royals, Athletics +6 · 2007-2021229 SV, 3.11 ERA, 831 K84
  13. 13Harry GumbertPirates, Giants, Reds +1 · 1935-195048 SV, 3.68 ERA, 709 K83
  14. 14Ron KlinePirates, Rangers, Twins +6 · 1952-1970108 SV, 3.75 ERA, 989 K83
  15. 15Bill SwiftPirates, White Sox, Dodgers +1 · 1932-194320 SV, 3.58 ERA, 636 K82
  16. 16Roy FacePirates, Nationals, Tigers · 1953-1969193 SV, 3.48 ERA, 877 K82
  17. 17Dan PlesacPirates, Brewers, Blue Jays +3 · 1986-2003158 SV, 3.64 ERA, 1,041 K81
  18. 18Miguel BatistaPirates, Nationals, Diamondbacks +8 · 1992-201241 SV, 4.48 ERA, 1,250 K81
  19. 19Terry MulhollandPirates, Phillies, Cubs +8 · 1986-20065 SV, 4.41 ERA, 1,325 K81
  20. 20Alejandro PeñaPirates, Dodgers, Mets +3 · 1981-199674 SV, 3.11 ERA, 839 K80
  21. 21Pedro RamosPirates, Twins, Guardians +4 · 1955-197055 SV, 4.08 ERA, 1,305 K80
  22. 22Dennis LampPirates, Red Sox, Blue Jays +3 · 1977-199235 SV, 3.93 ERA, 857 K79
  23. 23Dick HallPirates, Orioles, Phillies +1 · 1952-197168 SV, 3.32 ERA, 741 K79
  24. 24Octavio DotelPirates, Astros, White Sox +10 · 1999-2013109 SV, 3.78 ERA, 1,143 K79
  25. 25Bob MillerPirates, Dodgers, Mets +7 · 1957-197451 SV, 3.37 ERA, 895 K78

About this pool

Who is the highest rated player in the All-time Pirates pool?
Gene Tenace (catcher, Pirates, Athletics +2) at 99, from .241/.388/.429, 201 HR, 674 RBI.
Who is the best catcher to draft from the All-time Pirates pool?
Gene Tenace is rated 99: .241/.388/.429, 201 HR, 674 RBI.
Who is the best first baseman to draft from the All-time Pirates pool?
Hank Greenberg is rated 99: .313/.412/.605, 331 HR, 1,276 RBI.
Who is the best second baseman to draft from the All-time Pirates pool?
Billy Herman is rated 99: .304/.367/.407, 47 HR, 839 RBI.
Who is the best third baseman to draft from the All-time Pirates pool?
Bob Elliott is rated 99: .289/.375/.440, 170 HR, 1,195 RBI.
How many players can be drafted from the All-time Pirates pool?
418 players, the best at each position deep enough for eight teams to fill every lineup slot about three times over. Everyone who played for the Pittsburgh Pirates franchise, in every city it has called home.

Other MLB pools