Skip to main content
parlae.ioBeta
Sign in

All-time Yankees MLB draft pool

Everyone who played for the New York Yankees franchise, in every city it has called home. 425 players you can draft, each rated 40 to 99 from real stats. Ratings updated October 10, 2026.

Draft from this pool How the ratings work
Berra99Gehrig99Cano99Boggs99Rodriguez99Ruth99Encarnacion99Clemens99Rivera99Mantle97Johnson97Gossage96

CCatchers

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Yogi BerraYankees, Mets · 1946-1965.285/.348/.482, 358 HR, 1,430 RBI99
  2. 2Bill DickeyYankees · 1928-1946.313/.382/.486, 202 HR, 1,209 RBI93
  3. 3Ivan RodriguezYankees, Rangers, Tigers +3 · 1991-2011.296/.334/.464, 311 HR, 1,332 RBI90
  4. 4Jorge PosadaYankees · 1995-2011.273/.374/.474, 275 HR, 1,065 RBI88
  5. 5Roger BresnahanYankees, Giants, Cardinals +2 · 1897-1915.279/.386/.377, 26 HR, 530 RBI86
  6. 6Brian McCannYankees, Braves, Astros · 2005-2019.262/.337/.452, 282 HR, 1,018 RBI85
  7. 7Thurman MunsonYankees · 1969-1979.292/.346/.410, 113 HR, 701 RBI83
  8. 8Elston HowardYankees, Red Sox · 1955-1968.274/.322/.427, 167 HR, 762 RBI82
  9. 9Sherm LollarYankees, White Sox, Orioles +1 · 1946-1963.264/.357/.402, 155 HR, 808 RBI81
  10. 10Wally SchangYankees, Athletics, Orioles +2 · 1913-1931.284/.393/.401, 59 HR, 710 RBI81
  11. 11Mike StanleyYankees, Red Sox, Rangers +2 · 1986-2000.270/.370/.458, 187 HR, 702 RBI80
  12. 12Russell MartinYankees, Dodgers, Blue Jays +1 · 2006-2019.248/.349/.397, 191 HR, 771 RBI79
  13. 13Deacon McGuireYankees, WAS, Dodgers +5 · 1885-1912.278/.340/.370, 36 HR, 708 RBI78
  14. 14Gus TriandosYankees, Orioles, Tigers +2 · 1953-1965.244/.322/.413, 167 HR, 608 RBI78
  15. 15Bubbles HargraveYankees, Reds, Cubs · 1913-1930.310/.372/.452, 29 HR, 376 RBI77
  16. 16Steve O'NeillYankees, Guardians, Red Sox +1 · 1911-1928.263/.349/.337, 13 HR, 537 RBI77
  17. 17Don SlaughtYankees, Pirates, Rangers +4 · 1982-1997.283/.338/.412, 77 HR, 476 RBI76
  18. 18Duke SimsYankees, Guardians, Dodgers +2 · 1964-1974.239/.340/.401, 100 HR, 310 RBI76
  19. 19Aaron RobinsonYankees, Tigers, White Sox +1 · 1943-1951.260/.375/.412, 61 HR, 272 RBI75
  20. 20Gary SanchezYankees, Twins, Brewers +3 · 2015-2025.224/.309/.461, 189 HR, 509 RBI75
  21. 21Hank SevereidYankees, Orioles, Reds +1 · 1911-1926.289/.342/.367, 17 HR, 539 RBI75
  22. 22Butch WynegarYankees, Twins, Angels · 1976-1988.255/.348/.347, 65 HR, 506 RBI74
  23. 23Matt NokesYankees, Tigers, Orioles +2 · 1985-1995.254/.308/.441, 136 HR, 422 RBI74
  24. 24Ron HasseyYankees, Guardians, Athletics +3 · 1978-1991.266/.340/.382, 71 HR, 438 RBI74
  25. 25Francisco CervelliYankees, Pirates, Marlins +1 · 2008-2020.268/.358/.382, 41 HR, 275 RBI73

1BFirst basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Lou GehrigYankees · 1923-1939.340/.447/.632, 493 HR, 1,995 RBI99
  2. 2Johnny MizeYankees, Cardinals, Giants · 1936-1953.312/.397/.562, 359 HR, 1,337 RBI93
  3. 3Paul GoldschmidtYankees, Diamondbacks, Cardinals · 2011-2025.288/.378/.504, 372 HR, 1,232 RBI90
  4. 4Jason GiambiYankees, Athletics, Rockies +1 · 1995-2014.277/.399/.516, 440 HR, 1,441 RBI88
  5. 5John OlerudYankees, Blue Jays, Mariners +2 · 1989-2005.295/.398/.465, 255 HR, 1,230 RBI86
  6. 6Don MattinglyYankees · 1982-1995.307/.358/.471, 222 HR, 1,099 RBI85
  7. 7Mark TeixeiraYankees, Rangers, Braves +1 · 2003-2016.268/.360/.509, 409 HR, 1,298 RBI83
  8. 8Jack FournierYankees, Dodgers, White Sox +2 · 1912-1927.313/.392/.483, 136 HR, 859 RBI82
  9. 9Anthony RizzoYankees, Cubs, Padres · 2011-2024.261/.361/.467, 303 HR, 965 RBI81
  10. 10Frank ChanceYankees, Cubs · 1898-1914.296/.394/.394, 20 HR, 596 RBI81
  11. 11Bob WatsonYankees, Astros, Braves +1 · 1966-1984.295/.364/.447, 184 HR, 989 RBI80
  12. 12George ScottYankees, Red Sox, Brewers +1 · 1966-1979.268/.333/.435, 271 HR, 1,051 RBI79
  13. 13George BurnsYankees, Guardians, Tigers +2 · 1914-1929.307/.354/.429, 72 HR, 951 RBI78
  14. 14John MayberryYankees, Royals, Blue Jays +1 · 1968-1982.253/.360/.439, 255 HR, 879 RBI78
  15. 15Bill SkowronYankees, White Sox, Dodgers +2 · 1954-1967.282/.332/.459, 211 HR, 888 RBI77
  16. 16George McQuinnYankees, Orioles, Athletics +1 · 1936-1948.276/.357/.424, 135 HR, 794 RBI77
  17. 17Cecil FielderYankees, Tigers, Blue Jays +2 · 1985-1998.255/.345/.482, 319 HR, 1,008 RBI76
  18. 18Norm SiebernYankees, Athletics, Orioles +3 · 1956-1968.272/.369/.423, 132 HR, 636 RBI76
  19. 19Chris ChamblissYankees, Braves, Guardians · 1971-1988.279/.334/.415, 185 HR, 972 RBI75
  20. 20Dan McGannYankees, Giants, Cardinals +4 · 1896-1908.284/.364/.381, 42 HR, 727 RBI75
  21. 21Tino MartinezYankees, Mariners, Cardinals +1 · 1990-2005.271/.344/.471, 339 HR, 1,271 RBI75
  22. 22Hal ChaseYankees, Reds, White Sox +1 · 1905-1919.288/.317/.379, 37 HR, 804 RBI74
  23. 23Kevin YoukilisYankees, Red Sox, White Sox · 2004-2013.281/.382/.478, 150 HR, 618 RBI74
  24. 24Richie SexsonYankees, Brewers, Mariners +2 · 1997-2008.261/.344/.507, 306 HR, 943 RBI74
  25. 25Earl TorgesonYankees, Braves, White Sox +2 · 1947-1961.265/.385/.417, 149 HR, 740 RBI73

2BSecond basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Robinson CanoYankees, Mariners, Mets +2 · 2005-2022.301/.351/.488, 335 HR, 1,306 RBI99
  2. 2Joe GordonYankees, Guardians · 1938-1950.268/.357/.466, 253 HR, 975 RBI93
  3. 3Tony LazzeriYankees, Cubs, Dodgers +1 · 1926-1939.292/.380/.467, 178 HR, 1,191 RBI90
  4. 4Jimmy WilliamsYankees, Pirates, Orioles · 1899-1909.275/.337/.396, 49 HR, 796 RBI88
  5. 5Del PrattYankees, Orioles, Red Sox +1 · 1912-1924.292/.345/.403, 43 HR, 970 RBI86
  6. 6Willie RandolphYankees, Dodgers, Brewers +3 · 1975-1992.276/.373/.351, 54 HR, 687 RBI85
  7. 7Chuck KnoblauchYankees, Twins, Royals · 1991-2002.289/.378/.406, 98 HR, 615 RBI83
  8. 8DJ LeMahieuYankees, Rockies, Cubs · 2011-2025.289/.350/.409, 126 HR, 663 RBI82
  9. 9Gil McDougaldYankees · 1951-1960.276/.356/.410, 112 HR, 576 RBI81
  10. 10Lonny FreyYankees, Reds, Dodgers +2 · 1933-1948.269/.359/.374, 61 HR, 549 RBI81
  11. 11Steve SaxYankees, Dodgers, White Sox +1 · 1981-1994.281/.335/.358, 54 HR, 550 RBI80
  12. 12Neil WalkerYankees, Pirates, Mets +3 · 2009-2020.267/.338/.426, 149 HR, 609 RBI79
  13. 13Brian RobertsYankees, Orioles · 2001-2014.276/.347/.409, 97 HR, 542 RBI78
  14. 14Snuffy StirnweissYankees, Orioles, Guardians · 1943-1952.268/.362/.371, 29 HR, 281 RBI78
  15. 15Gleyber TorresYankees, Tigers · 2018-2025.264/.337/.433, 154 HR, 515 RBI77
  16. 16Jerry PriddyYankees, Tigers, Twins +1 · 1941-1953.265/.353/.373, 61 HR, 541 RBI77
  17. 17Frank LaPorteYankees, Orioles, Twins +1 · 1905-1913.282/.330/.372, 9 HR, 397 RBI76
  18. 18Kelly JohnsonYankees, Braves, Diamondbacks +5 · 2005-2016.251/.330/.422, 155 HR, 550 RBI76
  19. 19Germany SchaeferYankees, Tigers, Twins +2 · 1901-1918.259/.319/.322, 9 HR, 301 RBI75
  20. 20John HummelYankees, Dodgers · 1905-1918.254/.316/.352, 29 HR, 394 RBI75
  21. 21Randy VelardeYankees, Angels, Athletics +1 · 1987-2002.276/.352/.408, 100 HR, 445 RBI75
  22. 22Jazz ChisholmYankees, Marlins · 2020-2025.248/.316/.454, 108 HR, 308 RBI74
  23. 23Jerry LumpeYankees, Athletics, Tigers · 1956-1967.268/.325/.356, 47 HR, 454 RBI74
  24. 24Mariano DuncanYankees, Phillies, Dodgers +2 · 1985-1997.267/.300/.388, 87 HR, 491 RBI74
  25. 25Bernie AllenYankees, Rangers, Twins +1 · 1962-1973.239/.314/.357, 73 HR, 352 RBI73

Advertisement

3BThird basemans

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Wade BoggsYankees, Red Sox, Rays · 1982-1999.328/.415/.443, 118 HR, 1,014 RBI99
  2. 2Home Run BakerYankees, Athletics · 1908-1922.307/.363/.442, 96 HR, 987 RBI93
  3. 3Josh DonaldsonYankees, Blue Jays, Athletics +4 · 2010-2023.261/.358/.489, 279 HR, 816 RBI90
  4. 4Graig NettlesYankees, Guardians, Padres +3 · 1967-1988.248/.329/.421, 390 HR, 1,314 RBI88
  5. 5Toby HarrahYankees, Rangers, Guardians · 1969-1986.264/.365/.395, 195 HR, 918 RBI86
  6. 6John McGrawYankees, BLO, Cardinals +1 · 1892-1907.336/.469/.411, 13 HR, 448 RBI85
  7. 7Matt CarpenterYankees, Cardinals, Padres · 2011-2024.259/.366/.449, 179 HR, 659 RBI83
  8. 8Robin VenturaYankees, White Sox, Mets +1 · 1989-2004.267/.362/.444, 294 HR, 1,182 RBI82
  9. 9Jim Ray HartYankees, Giants · 1963-1974.278/.345/.467, 170 HR, 578 RBI81
  10. 10Mike LowellYankees, Marlins, Red Sox · 1998-2010.279/.342/.464, 223 HR, 952 RBI81
  11. 11Todd ZeileYankees, Cardinals, Mets +8 · 1989-2004.265/.346/.423, 253 HR, 1,110 RBI80
  12. 12Eric ChavezYankees, Athletics, Diamondbacks · 1998-2014.268/.342/.475, 260 HR, 902 RBI79
  13. 13Mark ReynoldsYankees, Diamondbacks, Rockies +5 · 2007-2019.236/.328/.453, 298 HR, 871 RBI78
  14. 14Martin PradoYankees, Braves, Marlins +1 · 2006-2019.287/.335/.412, 100 HR, 609 RBI78
  15. 15Red RolfeYankees · 1931-1942.289/.360/.413, 69 HR, 497 RBI77
  16. 16Todd FrazierYankees, Reds, Mets +3 · 2011-2021.241/.318/.445, 218 HR, 640 RBI77
  17. 17Billy WerberYankees, Red Sox, Reds +2 · 1930-1942.271/.364/.392, 78 HR, 539 RBI76
  18. 18Pete WardYankees, White Sox, Orioles · 1962-1970.254/.339/.405, 98 HR, 427 RBI76
  19. 19Chase HeadleyYankees, Padres · 2007-2018.263/.342/.399, 130 HR, 596 RBI75
  20. 20Eddie FosterYankees, Twins, Red Sox +1 · 1910-1923.264/.329/.326, 6 HR, 451 RBI75
  21. 21Morgan EnsbergYankees, Astros, Padres · 2000-2008.263/.362/.468, 110 HR, 347 RBI75
  22. 22Billy JohnsonYankees, Cardinals · 1943-1953.271/.346/.391, 61 HR, 487 RBI74
  23. 23Eric SoderholmYankees, Twins, White Sox +1 · 1971-1980.264/.335/.421, 102 HR, 383 RBI74
  24. 24Wid ConroyYankees, Twins, Orioles +1 · 1901-1911.248/.301/.329, 22 HR, 452 RBI74
  25. 25Charlie HayesYankees, Phillies, Rockies +4 · 1988-2001.262/.316/.398, 144 HR, 740 RBI73

SSShortstops

Top 25 of 35
  1. 1Alex RodriguezYankees, Mariners, Rangers · 1994-2016.295/.380/.550, 696 HR, 2,086 RBI99
  2. 2Derek JeterYankees · 1995-2014.310/.377/.440, 260 HR, 1,311 RBI93
  3. 3Troy TulowitzkiYankees, Rockies, Blue Jays · 2006-2019.290/.361/.495, 225 HR, 780 RBI90
  4. 4Joe SewellYankees, Guardians · 1920-1933.312/.391/.413, 49 HR, 1,055 RBI88
  5. 5Tony FernandezYankees, Blue Jays, Padres +4 · 1983-2001.288/.347/.399, 94 HR, 844 RBI86
  6. 6Herman LongYankees, Braves, Tigers +1 · 1890-1904.277/.333/.384, 88 HR, 995 RBI85
  7. 7Phil RizzutoYankees · 1941-1956.273/.351/.355, 38 HR, 563 RBI83
  8. 8Kid ElberfeldYankees, Tigers, Twins +3 · 1898-1914.271/.355/.339, 10 HR, 535 RBI82
  9. 9Roy SmalleyYankees, Twins, Rangers +1 · 1975-1987.257/.345/.395, 163 HR, 694 RBI81
  10. 10Starlin CastroYankees, Cubs, Marlins +1 · 2010-2021.280/.319/.412, 138 HR, 678 RBI81
  11. 11Woodie HeldYankees, Guardians, Athletics +4 · 1954-1969.240/.331/.421, 179 HR, 559 RBI80
  12. 12Bert CampanerisYankees, Athletics, Rangers +1 · 1964-1983.259/.311/.342, 79 HR, 646 RBI79
  13. 13Bill KeisterYankees, BLO, Cardinals +3 · 1896-1903.312/.349/.440, 18 HR, 400 RBI78
  14. 14Roger PeckinpaughYankees, Twins, Guardians +1 · 1910-1927.259/.336/.335, 48 HR, 740 RBI78
  15. 15Lyn LaryYankees, Guardians, Orioles +4 · 1929-1940.269/.369/.372, 38 HR, 526 RBI77
  16. 16Stephen DrewYankees, Diamondbacks, Red Sox +2 · 2006-2017.252/.318/.423, 123 HR, 524 RBI77
  17. 17Frankie CrosettiYankees · 1932-1948.245/.341/.354, 98 HR, 649 RBI76
  18. 18Ron HansenYankees, White Sox, Orioles +2 · 1958-1972.234/.320/.351, 106 HR, 501 RBI76
  19. 19Didi GregoriusYankees, Phillies, Diamondbacks +1 · 2012-2022.257/.308/.420, 134 HR, 530 RBI75
  20. 20Marwin GonzalezYankees, Astros, Twins +1 · 2012-2022.252/.310/.399, 107 HR, 415 RBI75
  21. 21Tony KubekYankees · 1957-1965.266/.303/.364, 57 HR, 373 RBI75
  22. 22Amed RosarioYankees, Mets, Guardians +4 · 2017-2025.273/.308/.400, 69 HR, 389 RBI74
  23. 23Ivan de JesusYankees, Cubs, Phillies +4 · 1974-1988.254/.323/.326, 21 HR, 324 RBI74
  24. 24Spike OwenYankees, Nationals, Mariners +2 · 1983-1995.246/.324/.341, 46 HR, 439 RBI74
  25. 25Dick HowserYankees, Guardians, Athletics · 1961-1968.248/.346/.318, 16 HR, 165 RBI73

OFOutfielders

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Babe RuthYankees, Red Sox, Braves · 1914-1935.342/.474/.690, 714 HR, 2,217 RBI99
  2. 2Mickey MantleYankees · 1951-1968.298/.421/.557, 536 HR, 1,509 RBI97
  3. 3Reggie JacksonYankees, Athletics, Angels +1 · 1967-1987.262/.356/.490, 563 HR, 1,702 RBI95
  4. 4Gary SheffieldYankees, Marlins, Dodgers +5 · 1988-2009.292/.393/.514, 509 HR, 1,676 RBI93
  5. 5Joe DiMaggioYankees · 1936-1951.325/.398/.579, 361 HR, 1,537 RBI92
  6. 6Paul WanerYankees, Pirates, Braves +1 · 1926-1945.333/.404/.473, 113 HR, 1,309 RBI91
  7. 7Aaron JudgeYankees · 2016-2025.294/.413/.615, 368 HR, 830 RBI90
  8. 8Dave WinfieldYankees, Padres, Angels +3 · 1973-1995.283/.353/.475, 465 HR, 1,833 RBI89
  9. 9Rickey HendersonYankees, Athletics, Padres +6 · 1979-2003.279/.401/.419, 297 HR, 1,115 RBI89
  10. 10Lance BerkmanYankees, Astros, Cardinals +1 · 1999-2013.293/.406/.537, 366 HR, 1,234 RBI88
  11. 11Enos SlaughterYankees, Cardinals, Athletics +1 · 1938-1959.300/.382/.453, 169 HR, 1,304 RBI87
  12. 12Tim RainesYankees, Nationals, White Sox +3 · 1979-2002.294/.385/.425, 170 HR, 980 RBI87
  13. 13Matt HollidayYankees, Cardinals, Rockies +1 · 2004-2018.299/.379/.510, 316 HR, 1,220 RBI86
  14. 14Willie KeelerYankees, BLO, Dodgers +1 · 1892-1910.341/.388/.415, 33 HR, 810 RBI86
  15. 15Andrew McCutchenYankees, Pirates, Phillies +2 · 2009-2025.271/.365/.457, 332 HR, 1,152 RBI85
  16. 16Joe KelleyYankees, BLO, Reds +3 · 1891-1908.317/.402/.451, 65 HR, 1,194 RBI85
  17. 17Bobby AbreuYankees, Phillies, Angels +3 · 1996-2014.291/.395/.475, 288 HR, 1,363 RBI84
  18. 18Carlos BeltranYankees, Mets, Royals +4 · 1998-2017.279/.350/.486, 435 HR, 1,587 RBI84
  19. 19Giancarlo StantonYankees, Marlins · 2010-2025.258/.345/.528, 453 HR, 1,169 RBI83
  20. 20Jack ClarkYankees, Giants, Cardinals +2 · 1975-1992.267/.379/.476, 340 HR, 1,180 RBI83
  21. 21Rocky ColavitoYankees, Guardians, Tigers +3 · 1955-1968.266/.359/.489, 374 HR, 1,159 RBI83
  22. 22Darryl StrawberryYankees, Mets, Dodgers +1 · 1983-1999.259/.357/.505, 335 HR, 1,000 RBI82
  23. 23Jim WynnYankees, Astros, Dodgers +2 · 1963-1977.250/.366/.436, 291 HR, 964 RBI82
  24. 24Jose CansecoYankees, Athletics, Red Sox +4 · 1985-2001.266/.353/.515, 462 HR, 1,407 RBI82
  25. 25Bobby BondsYankees, Giants, Angels +5 · 1968-1981.268/.353/.471, 332 HR, 1,024 RBI81

DHDesignated hitters

Top 10 of 10
  1. 1Edwin EncarnacionYankees, Blue Jays, Reds +3 · 2005-2020.260/.350/.496, 424 HR, 1,261 RBI99
  2. 2Don BaylorYankees, Angels, Orioles +3 · 1970-1988.260/.342/.436, 338 HR, 1,276 RBI93
  3. 3Travis HafnerYankees, Guardians, Rangers · 2002-2013.273/.376/.498, 213 HR, 731 RBI90
  4. 4Billy ButlerYankees, Royals, Athletics · 2007-2016.290/.354/.441, 147 HR, 728 RBI88
  5. 5Cliff JohnsonYankees, Blue Jays, Astros +4 · 1972-1986.258/.355/.459, 196 HR, 699 RBI86
  6. 6Kendrys MoralesYankees, Angels, Royals +4 · 2006-2019.265/.327/.453, 213 HR, 740 RBI85
  7. 7Ken PhelpsYankees, Mariners, Athletics +3 · 1980-1990.239/.374/.480, 123 HR, 313 RBI83
  8. 8Ron BlombergYankees, White Sox · 1969-1978.293/.360/.473, 52 HR, 224 RBI82
  9. 9Josh PhelpsYankees, Blue Jays, Pirates +3 · 2000-2008.273/.343/.472, 64 HR, 244 RBI81
  10. 10Kevin MaasYankees, Twins · 1990-1995.230/.329/.422, 65 HR, 169 RBI81

SPStarting pitchers

Top 25 of 90
  1. 1Roger ClemensYankees, Red Sox, Astros +1 · 1984-2007354-184, 3.12 ERA, 4,672 K99
  2. 2Randy JohnsonYankees, Mariners, Diamondbacks +3 · 1988-2009303-166, 3.29 ERA, 4,875 K97
  3. 3Gaylord PerryYankees, Giants, Guardians +5 · 1962-1983314-265, 3.11 ERA, 3,534 K95
  4. 4Red RuffingYankees, Red Sox, White Sox · 1924-1947273-225, 3.80 ERA, 1,987 K93
  5. 5Mike MussinaYankees, Orioles · 1991-2008270-153, 3.68 ERA, 2,813 K92
  6. 6Whitey FordYankees · 1950-1967236-106, 2.75 ERA, 1,956 K91
  7. 7Kevin BrownYankees, Rangers, Dodgers +3 · 1986-2005211-144, 3.28 ERA, 2,397 K90
  8. 8Lefty GomezYankees, Twins · 1930-1943189-102, 3.34 ERA, 1,468 K89
  9. 9Phil NiekroYankees, Braves, Guardians +1 · 1964-1987318-274, 3.35 ERA, 3,342 K89
  10. 10CC SabathiaYankees, Guardians, Brewers · 2001-2019251-161, 3.74 ERA, 3,093 K88
  11. 11Dazzy VanceYankees, Dodgers, Cardinals +2 · 1915-1935197-140, 3.24 ERA, 2,045 K87
  12. 12Tommy JohnYankees, White Sox, Dodgers +3 · 1963-1989288-231, 3.34 ERA, 2,245 K87
  13. 13Clark GriffithYankees, Cubs, White Sox +2 · 1893-1914223-137, 3.28 ERA, 867 K86
  14. 14Waite HoytYankees, Pirates, Tigers +4 · 1918-1938237-182, 3.59 ERA, 1,206 K86
  15. 15Andy PettitteYankees, Astros · 1995-2013256-153, 3.85 ERA, 2,448 K85
  16. 16David ConeYankees, Mets, Royals +2 · 1986-2003194-126, 3.46 ERA, 2,668 K85
  17. 17Burleigh GrimesYankees, Dodgers, Pirates +4 · 1916-1934270-212, 3.53 ERA, 1,512 K84
  18. 18Stan CoveleskiYankees, Guardians, Twins +1 · 1912-1928215-142, 2.89 ERA, 981 K84
  19. 19Catfish HunterYankees, Athletics · 1965-1979224-166, 3.26 ERA, 2,012 K83
  20. 20Frank TananaYankees, Tigers, Angels +3 · 1973-1993240-236, 3.66 ERA, 2,773 K83
  21. 21Herb PennockYankees, Red Sox, Athletics · 1912-1934240-162, 3.60 ERA, 1,227 K83
  22. 22Jim KaatYankees, Twins, Cardinals +2 · 1959-1983283-237, 3.45 ERA, 2,461 K82
  23. 23Jimmy KeyYankees, Blue Jays, Orioles · 1984-1998186-117, 3.51 ERA, 1,538 K82
  24. 24Joe McGinnityYankees, Giants, BLO +1 · 1899-1908246-142, 2.66 ERA, 1,068 K82
  25. 25Bartolo ColonYankees, Guardians, Mets +8 · 1997-2018247-188, 4.12 ERA, 2,535 K81

RPRelief pitchers

Top 25 of 60
  1. 1Mariano RiveraYankees · 1995-2013652 SV, 2.21 ERA, 1,173 K99
  2. 2Rich GossageYankees, Padres, White Sox +6 · 1972-1994310 SV, 3.01 ERA, 1,502 K96
  3. 3Tom GordonYankees, Royals, Red Sox +5 · 1988-2009158 SV, 3.96 ERA, 1,928 K93
  4. 4Lee SmithYankees, Cubs, Cardinals +5 · 1980-1997478 SV, 3.03 ERA, 1,251 K92
  5. 5Bobby ShantzYankees, Athletics, Cardinals +4 · 1949-196448 SV, 3.38 ERA, 1,072 K90
  6. 6Aroldis ChapmanYankees, Reds, Pirates +4 · 2010-2025367 SV, 2.52 ERA, 1,331 K89
  7. 7Sparky LyleYankees, Red Sox, Rangers +2 · 1967-1982238 SV, 2.88 ERA, 873 K88
  8. 8Dave RighettiYankees, Giants, Blue Jays +2 · 1979-1995252 SV, 3.46 ERA, 1,112 K87
  9. 9Gerry StaleyYankees, Cardinals, White Sox +3 · 1947-196161 SV, 3.70 ERA, 727 K86
  10. 10Bob WickmanYankees, Brewers, Guardians +2 · 1992-2007267 SV, 3.57 ERA, 785 K85
  11. 11Lindy McDanielYankees, Cardinals, Cubs +2 · 1955-1975172 SV, 3.45 ERA, 1,361 K85
  12. 12John WettelandYankees, Rangers, Nationals +1 · 1989-2000330 SV, 2.93 ERA, 804 K84
  13. 13Armando BenitezYankees, Mets, Orioles +4 · 1994-2008289 SV, 3.13 ERA, 946 K83
  14. 14Rick HoneycuttYankees, Athletics, Dodgers +3 · 1977-199738 SV, 3.72 ERA, 1,038 K83
  15. 15Jesse OroscoYankees, Mets, Orioles +6 · 1979-2003144 SV, 3.16 ERA, 1,179 K82
  16. 16Kerry WoodYankees, Cubs, Guardians · 1998-201263 SV, 3.67 ERA, 1,582 K82
  17. 17Jeff ReardonYankees, Nationals, Twins +4 · 1979-1994367 SV, 3.16 ERA, 877 K81
  18. 18Johnny MurphyYankees, Red Sox · 1932-1947107 SV, 3.50 ERA, 378 K81
  19. 19Mark MelanconYankees, Pirates, Giants +6 · 2009-2022262 SV, 2.94 ERA, 643 K81
  20. 20David RobertsonYankees, White Sox, Rangers +5 · 2008-2025179 SV, 2.93 ERA, 1,176 K80
  21. 21Paul QuantrillYankees, Blue Jays, Dodgers +4 · 1992-200521 SV, 3.83 ERA, 725 K80
  22. 22Greg HarrisYankees, Red Sox, Rangers +5 · 1981-199554 SV, 3.69 ERA, 1,141 K79
  23. 23LaTroy HawkinsYankees, Twins, Rockies +8 · 1995-2015127 SV, 4.31 ERA, 983 K79
  24. 24Stan WilliamsYankees, Dodgers, Guardians +3 · 1958-197243 SV, 3.48 ERA, 1,305 K79
  25. 25Pedro RamosYankees, Twins, Guardians +4 · 1955-197055 SV, 4.08 ERA, 1,305 K78

About this pool

Who is the highest rated player in the All-time Yankees pool?
Yogi Berra (catcher, Yankees, Mets) at 99, from .285/.348/.482, 358 HR, 1,430 RBI.
Who is the best catcher to draft from the All-time Yankees pool?
Yogi Berra is rated 99: .285/.348/.482, 358 HR, 1,430 RBI.
Who is the best first baseman to draft from the All-time Yankees pool?
Lou Gehrig is rated 99: .340/.447/.632, 493 HR, 1,995 RBI.
Who is the best second baseman to draft from the All-time Yankees pool?
Robinson Cano is rated 99: .301/.351/.488, 335 HR, 1,306 RBI.
Who is the best third baseman to draft from the All-time Yankees pool?
Wade Boggs is rated 99: .328/.415/.443, 118 HR, 1,014 RBI.
How many players can be drafted from the All-time Yankees pool?
425 players, the best at each position deep enough for eight teams to fill every lineup slot about three times over. Everyone who played for the New York Yankees franchise, in every city it has called home.

Other MLB pools