Clayton Keller or William Nylander? Week 4
Points leagues, Week 4 (Oct 19-25): start William Nylander. Both count 1 games left in Week 4 (Oct 19-25), so it comes down to value per game: 2.5 fantasy points to 2.4. Who to start in fantasy hockey in Week 4 (Oct 19-25), RWs ranked 6th and 9th at the position.
Updated Oct 23, 2:49 AM ET. Rechecked every 30 minutes.
Parlae may earn a commission from price links.
The Week 4 call
Points leagues, Week 4 (Oct 19-25): start William Nylander. Both count 1 games left in Week 4 (Oct 19-25), so it comes down to value per game: 2.5 fantasy points to 2.4.
Categories leagues: Clayton Keller instead, 2.2 category value for the week to 0.7, because his category mix is worth more there.
Over UTA's last 5 games Clayton Keller played 5 games, 17:39 a night with 3:10 on the power play: line 1 by even-strength ice time and the first power-play unit.
Over TOR's last 5 games William Nylander played 5 games, 20:21 a night with 3:58 on the power play: line 1 by even-strength ice time and the first power-play unit.
TOR has a back-to-back in Week 4.
This is the call for one lineup slot across the week, the way weekly-lock leagues play it. In a daily-lineup league, start whichever of the two plays that night, and both when they fit.
Week 4 (Oct 19-25), side by side
| This week | Clayton Keller | William Nylander |
|---|---|---|
| Games, Week 4 | 3 | 4 |
| Games counted (left this week) | 1 | 1 |
| Back-to-backs | 0 | 1 |
| Games, Week 5 | 3 | 3 |
| Line by ice time | Line 1 | Line 1 |
| Power-play unit | PP1 | PP1 |
| TOI, last games | 17:39 (5) | 20:21 (5) |
| TOI, board | 18:40 | 19:47 |
| PP TOI, last games | 3:10 | 3:58 |
| Shots, last games | 1.6 | 2.4 |
| Injury | None listed | None listed |
| Projected fantasy points | 2.4 | 2.5 |
| Projected category value | 2.2 | 0.7 |
Schedule: Clayton Keller Mon PIT, Thu @SEA, Sat TBL. William Nylander Mon SJS, Tue @CBJ, Thu NYR, Sat @EDM.
Projections are the board's per-game value times the games counted. A skater listed out, or who missed his team's last three games, counts none. A goalie counts his team's games times his share of its recent starts. Lines and power-play units are by ice time over the team's last five games. Stats and schedule from the NHL; injury designations from ESPN's public NHL injury list.
Advertisement
The rest-of-season call
Season-long, points leagues: William Nylander, 2.53 fantasy points per game to 2.36.
Categories leagues: Clayton Keller instead, 45th overall against 73rd, because the categories reward a different mix.
| Category (z per game) | Clayton Keller | William Nylander |
|---|---|---|
| A assists | 1.5 | 1.4 |
| G goals | 0.2 | 1.2 |
| +/- plus-minus | -0.2 | -1.4 |
| BLK blocked shots | -0.6 | -0.8 |
| HIT hits | -1.0 | -1.1 |
| PPP power-play points | 1.8 | 1.1 |
| SOG shots on goal | 0.4 | 0.3 |
Other close calls
Week 4 streamers and goalie starts · NHL waiver wire · Rest-of-season rankings
Common questions
Should I start Clayton Keller or William Nylander in Week 4?
Points leagues, Week 4 (Oct 19-25): start William Nylander. Both count 1 games left in Week 4 (Oct 19-25), so it comes down to value per game: 2.5 fantasy points to 2.4. Categories leagues: Clayton Keller instead, 2.2 category value for the week to 0.7, because his category mix is worth more there. Over UTA's last 5 games Clayton Keller played 5 games, 17:39 a night with 3:10 on the power play: line 1 by even-strength ice time and the first power-play unit. Over TOR's last 5 games William Nylander played 5 games, 20:21 a night with 3:58 on the power play: line 1 by even-strength ice time and the first power-play unit. TOR has a back-to-back in Week 4.
Who is better for the rest of the season, Clayton Keller or William Nylander?
Season-long, points leagues: William Nylander, 2.53 fantasy points per game to 2.36. Categories leagues: Clayton Keller instead, 45th overall against 73rd, because the categories reward a different mix.
Who wins more categories, Clayton Keller or William Nylander?
Clayton Keller is ahead per game in 5 (assists, plus-minus, blocked shots, hits, power-play points); William Nylander in 1 (goals).
By the Parlae deskBoard updated Oct 23, 2026 at 2:49 AM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number