Skip to main content

Should I drop J.J. McCarthy? Drop him.

Yes. J.J. McCarthy projects 15.1 PPR points a game the rest of the season, below a replacement QB.

J.J. McCarthy
QB, NYG

Verdict

Verdict
Drop
Rest of season
QB20
Week 10 projection
16.0
Target share
-

Why

  • J.J. McCarthy is QB20 on our rest of season ranking: 15.1 projected PPR points a game over his 8 games left through Week 17, 1.6 a game below a replacement QB (16.7).
  • Week 10: 16.0 projected PPR points (vs. WAS), QB13 on this week's board. That defense allows the 5th most fantasy points to his position.
  • He played 76% of his team's snaps over his last games, through Week 9.
  • He is listed questionable.
  • Across Sleeper leagues he was dropped 46,953 times and added 29,295 times in the busiest 24 hours we measured this week.

Rest of season figures are projected PPR points a game from Week 10 through Week 17, measured against a replacement level starter at his position. Shares compare his last game with his games before it.

Who to add instead

Add Tyler Shough (NO) instead, 16.9 projected PPR points a game rest of season. He drew 181,088 adds in his busiest 24 hours this waiver cycle.

Tyler Shough fantasy outlook

Should I drop these QBs?

By the Parlae deskVerdict updated Nov 10, 2026 at 10:22 PM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number