1. 2025 Bowman University Chrome #1 on eBay
Prospect
Topps, prospect, 1st Bowman; college card (Oklahoma).
Best John Mateer cards: 1st Bowman and college cards
John Mateer's cards, with every card number from a cited checklist. Started at Washington State in 2024 and accounted for 44 total touchdowns. The checklist below lists 11 college cards by card number, each row from a cited source. College cards are not rookie cards: those follow the first pro season.
Parlae may earn a commission on purchases through these links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Top 5 John Mateer cards
See all 11- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
2. 2025 Bowman University Chrome Prospect Autographs #BCA-JM on eBay
Auto
Topps, autograph, College autograph (Oklahoma).
3. 2025 Bowman University Best #27 on eBay
Prospect
Topps, prospect, College base card (Oklahoma).
Sources [1]
4. 2025 Bowman University Best - The Best of 2025 Autographs #BOA-JMA on eBay
Auto
Topps, autograph, College autograph (Oklahoma).
Sources [1]
5. 2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs #55AV-JM (/99) on eBay
AutoNumbered /99
Topps, autograph.
Sources [1]
Which John Mateer card is the real rookie card
Mateer's Bowman U cards are licensed Oklahoma college cards from Topps. His 2025 Bowman University Chrome base card #1 is marked 1st on the checklist. College cards, not rookie cards.
Sources [1]
Advertisement
John Mateer's career, in brief
- Started at Washington State in 2024 and accounted for 44 total touchdowns.
- Transferred to Oklahoma and threw for 392 yards in his 2025 debut, a school record for a first game.
- Returned to Oklahoma for 2026 as a senior.
Career facts: [1]
John Mateer card checklist
11 cards with card numbers, each from the checklist linked on its row. A row marked "one source" is printed by one checklist site only. Parallels are counted, not listed.
CardTypePrint runRCPrice
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome #1 on eBay1st Bowman; college card (Oklahoma) [1][2]Prospect · Not numberedProspectNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Prospect Autographs #BCA-JM on eBayCollege autograph (Oklahoma) [1][2]Auto · Not numberedAutoNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Best #27 on eBayCollege base card (Oklahoma) [1]Prospect · Not numberedProspectNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Best - The Best of 2025 Autographs #BOA-JMA on eBayCollege autograph (Oklahoma) [1]Auto · Not numberedAutoNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football Autographs #55AV-JM on eBayone source [1]Auto · /99Auto/99No
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome 1955 Bowman Football #55AV-12 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Acropolis #A-4 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome College Rule Playbook #CRP-14 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Dean's List Refractor #DL-9 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Lettered Up! #LU-10 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
- 2025 Bowman University Chrome Path to Glory #PG-20 on eBayone source [1]Insert · Not numberedInsertNot numberedNo
Find John Mateer in sealed boxes
2025 Bowman University Chrome Football Bowman University Chrome #1, his 1st Bowman
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Graded John Mateer rookie cards: PSA 10, BGS and CGC
A PSA 10 (Gem Mint) or BGS 9.5 is the top grade most collectors look for: sharp corners, clean edges, centered printing and an unmarked surface. A graded card and a raw one are different cards to look up. How the four graders compare and what grading costs.
How PSA, CGC and Beckett grade
PSA
- Top grades:
- Gem Mint 10, then Mint 9 and NM-MT 8.
- Half grades:
- 1.5 through 8.5 since February 2008; there is no PSA 9.5.
One overall grade on the label. Centering weighs heavily in it.
CGC
- Top grades:
- Pristine 10 (virtually flawless, 50/50 centering), then Gem Mint 10 and Mint+ 9.5.
- Half grades:
- Yes, from Fair 1.5 up to Mint+ 9.5.
Authentic (AU) for a genuine card that cannot take a number; Authentic Altered (AA) for one that was altered.
Source: CGC grading scale
Beckett (BGS)
- Top grades:
- Pristine 10; a Black Label Pristine 10 has a 10 in all four subgrades.
- Half grades:
- Yes, 1 to 10 in half points.
Four subgrades on the label: centering, corners, edges and surface.
Source: Beckett grading
Grading scales as each grader describes them, checked Oct 16, 2026.
Advertisement
John Mateer card questions
What is John Mateer's rookie card?
- John Mateer's licensed rookie cards are not in our checklist yet. The first prospect card is the 2025 Bowman University Chrome #1, which is not a rookie card; NFL and NBA rookie cards follow the first pro season.
Does John Mateer have a rookie card yet?
- Not yet. Rookie cards follow the first pro season. Our checklist lists 11 John Mateer college cards with card numbers, each from a cited source.
What is John Mateer's 1st Bowman card?
- The 2025 Bowman University Chrome #1, a college card, so not a rookie card: rookie cards follow the first pro season.
How much is a John Mateer rookie card worth?
- Parlae does not print card values. Find the year, set, card number, parallel and grade on your card, then check eBay sold listings or eBay's price guide for that exact card.
Does John Mateer have a PSA 10?
- PSA's population report says how many PSA 10s exist of each card; Parlae does not reprint it. To see PSA 10 copies listed now, use "Check PSA 10 prices" beside each card above.
Most searched college cards
More from Parlae
Collector attention
Not enough lookups to measure this week.
Card facts checked 2026-10-19. Parlae prints no card values. Set and brand names belong to their makers; Parlae is not affiliated with them.
Gift guides
Best sports card gifts · Best boxes to gift · Card gifts for kids · Stocking stuffers · Gifts for collectors · Football card gifts · Basketball card gifts · Baseball card gifts · Card gifts by age · All card guides
By the Parlae deskCard data updated Oct 19, 2026 at 10:22 AM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number