Skip to main content
parlae.ioBeta
Sign in

Buffalo Bills rookie cards: the key rookie card of every player we cover

The Buffalo Bills player collectors look up most is Josh Allen, whose key rookie card is the 2018 Donruss #304. Below, the key rookie card of each of the 6 Buffalo Bills players with a sourced card page, then the club's rookies and second-year players, all by collector interest.

Attention measures how much people are looking up this player, a leading indicator collectors watch. It is not a price. Source: Wikipedia pageviews through 2026-10-15.

Buffalo Bills key rookie cards

By our printed criteria, from each player's cited checklist.

  1. 1

    Josh AllenBUF QB

    Key RC: 2018 Donruss #304

    505,355 lookups in 30 daysup 209% this weekSurging

  2. 2

    DJ MooreBUF WR

    Key RC: 2018 Donruss #316

    46,178 lookups in 30 daysup 7% this weekFlat

  3. 3

    Keon ColemanBUF WR

    Key RC: 2024 Donruss #358

    32,463 lookups in 30 daysdown 7% this weekFlat

  4. 4

    Khalil ShakirBUF WR

    Key RC: 2022 Donruss #343

    15,432 lookups in 30 daysup 156% this weekSurging

  5. 5

    Greg DortchBUF WR

    Key RC: 2019 Score #435

    12,460 lookups in 30 daysup 72% this weekSurging

  6. 6

    Ty JohnsonBUF RB

    Key RC: 2019 Donruss #295

    7,293 lookups in 30 daysup 405% this weekSurging

How this list is ranked

Collector interest is how many people looked each player up on Wikipedia: the last 30 days for the ranking, the last 7 against the 7 before for the weekly change. It measures attention, not what any card sells for, and Parlae prints no card values. A key rookie card is picked by the criteria printed on each player's card page, from his sourced checklist.

By the Parlae deskCard lists updated Oct 16, 2026 at 12:22 PM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number