Skip to main content

Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving? Week 5

Who to start in fantasy basketball in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), SGs ranked 10th and 11th at the position, compared on 2025-26 and 2026-27 per-game production.

Updated Nov 17, 6:58 AM ET.

FP/G
37.4
9-cat
#17
Last 10 FP
38.2

Out (Knee)

4 games in Week 5, 1 back-to-back

PGDALDTD
FP/G
36.9
9-cat
#16
Last 10 FP
38.4

Day to day (Knee)

3 games in Week 5, 1 back-to-back

Week 5 pick in points and 9-cat leagues.

The Week 5 call

Jimmy Butler III is listed Out (Knee) on Sleeper, so his projection counts no games while that stands.

Points leagues, Week 5 (Nov 16-22): start Kyrie Irving. Kyrie Irving has 3 games counted to 0 for Jimmy Butler III, for 110.6 projected fantasy points against 0.0.

9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving again, 9.4 category value for the week to 0.0.

Kyrie Irving has 1 back-to-back in Week 5, the nights rest days tend to land on.

Jimmy Butler III's minutes are down: 27.1 a game over his last 5 games of 2025-26, against 31.1 on the board.

Kyrie Irving played 31.8 minutes a game over his last 5 games of 2026-27, in line with his 30.7 on the board.

This is the call for one lineup slot across the week, the way weekly-lock leagues play it. In a daily-lineup league, start whichever of the two plays that night, and both when they fit.

Week 5 (Nov 16-22), side by side

This weekJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
Games, Week 543
Games counted (left this week)03
Back-to-backs11
Games, Week 632
Minutes, last games27.1 (last 5)31.8 (last 5)
Minutes, board31.130.7
Shots per 36, last games18.320.1
InjuryOut (Knee)Day to day (Knee)
Projected fantasy points0.0110.6
Projected 9-cat value0.09.4

Schedule: Jimmy Butler III Mon @NOP, Wed @DAL, Thu @MEM, Sun BOS. Kyrie Irving Wed GSW, Sat LAC, Sun @UTA.

Projected totals for the games counted

StatJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
Points0.068.2
Rebounds0.010.4
Assists0.013.1
Steals0.03.8
Blocks0.01.4
Threes0.010.6
Turnovers0.05.2

Each projection is the board's per-game line times the games counted; a player listed Out counts none. 9-cat value is the per-game category score (z-scores against the top 156) times games. Minutes and shots per 36 come from the last 5 games of 2025-26. Schedule from the NBA's published slate via ESPN.

The season-long call

Points leagues: Jimmy Butler III, 37.4 fantasy points per game to 36.9.

9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving instead, 16th overall against 17th, because the categories reward a different mix.

Jimmy Butler III vs Kyrie Irving: the full comparison, per 36 and by punt build

Per game, side by side

StatJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
Fantasy points per game37.436.9
Minutes31.130.7
PointsPTS20.022.7
ReboundsREB5.63.5
AssistsAST4.94.4
StealsSTL1.41.3
BlocksBLK0.20.5
Threes3PM0.83.5
Field goal %FG%51.9%47.4%
Free throw %FT%86.4%86.1%
TurnoversTO1.61.7

Bold is the better number. Per-game lines blend last season with this one, the same numbers the rankings use.

Other close calls

Week 5 streamers · NBA waiver wire · Games per team this week

Is Jimmy Butler III playing tonight? · Is Kyrie Irving playing tonight?

Your next move

Common questions

  • Should I start Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving in Week 5?

    Jimmy Butler III is listed Out (Knee) on Sleeper, so his projection counts no games while that stands. Points leagues, Week 5 (Nov 16-22): start Kyrie Irving. Kyrie Irving has 3 games counted to 0 for Jimmy Butler III, for 110.6 projected fantasy points against 0.0. 9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving again, 9.4 category value for the week to 0.0. Kyrie Irving has 1 back-to-back in Week 5, the nights rest days tend to land on. Jimmy Butler III's minutes are down: 27.1 a game over his last 5 games of 2025-26, against 31.1 on the board. Kyrie Irving played 31.8 minutes a game over his last 5 games of 2026-27, in line with his 30.7 on the board.

  • Who is better for the season, Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving?

    Points leagues: Jimmy Butler III, 37.4 fantasy points per game to 36.9. 9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving instead, 16th overall against 17th, because the categories reward a different mix.

  • Who wins more categories, Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving?

    Jimmy Butler III is ahead in 6 (rebounds, assists, steals, field goal percentage, free throw percentage, turnovers); Kyrie Irving in 3 (points, blocks, threes), per game.

By the Parlae deskBoard updated Nov 17, 2026 at 6:58 AM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number