Skip to main content

Jimmy Butler III vs Kyrie Irving: who to start in Week 5

Jimmy Butler III plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Kyrie Irving 3. For that week alone, start Kyrie Irving: 110.6 projected fantasy points to 0.0 for Jimmy Butler III. Over the season, Jimmy Butler III leads in points leagues (37.4 fantasy points a game to 36.9) and Kyrie Irving in 9-cat leagues (16th against 17th). The two go close together on our board, which is our own ranking order from 2025-26 and 2026-27 box scores, not ADP.

Updated Nov 17, 6:58 AM ET.

Parlae may earn a commission from price links.

SFPFSGGSWage 37OUT
Points leagues
#38
37.4 FP/G, slot 4.02, $22
9-cat leagues
#17
+3.0 z, slot 2.05, $31

Out (Knee)

The pick in points leagues.

PGSGDALage 34DTD
Points leagues
#42
36.9 FP/G, slot 4.06, $21
9-cat leagues
#16
+3.1 z, slot 2.04, $32

Day to day (Knee)

The pick in 9-cat leagues.

The call

Points leagues: Jimmy Butler III. 37.4 fantasy points per game against 36.9, 38th on our board to 42nd.

9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving instead, +3.1 in summed z-scores against +3.0 (16th to 17th), because the categories pay for a different mix.

Category by category, Jimmy Butler III is ahead in 6 (REB, AST, STL, FG%, FT% and TO) and Kyrie Irving in 3 (PTS, BLK and 3PM).

Jimmy Butler III plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Kyrie Irving 3. For that week alone, start Kyrie Irving: 110.6 projected fantasy points to 0.0 for Jimmy Butler III.

Slots are where our board's order lands in a 12-team snake draft (round.pick), and dollars are auction value over replacement for 12 teams with $200 each. Neither is ADP: no free draft-position feed lets us republish it.

Per game, side by side

Per gameJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
Fantasy points per game37.436.9
Minutes31.130.7
PointsPTS20.022.7
ReboundsREB5.63.5
AssistsAST4.94.4
StealsSTL1.41.3
BlocksBLK0.20.5
Threes3PM0.83.5
Field goal %FG%51.9%47.4%
Free throw %FT%86.4%86.1%
TurnoversTO1.61.7
Games, 2025-26380

Bold is the better number. The line blends 2025-26 with 2026-27 games as they are played, the same numbers the rankings use.

Per 36 minutes

Per 36Jimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
Fantasy points43.243.2
Points23.126.6
Rebounds6.44.0
Assists5.65.1
Steals1.71.5
Blocks0.20.5
Threes1.04.2
Turnovers1.82.0

Each per-game number divided by minutes and scaled to 36: the rate a bigger role would carry.

9-category z-scores

CategoryJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
PointsPTS+0.6+1.1
ReboundsREB-0.1-0.9
AssistsAST+0.6+0.3
StealsSTL+1.0+0.6
BlocksBLK-0.9-0.4
Threes3PM-0.9+1.9
Field goal percentageFG%+0.8-0.2
Free throw percentageFT%+1.4+0.6
TurnoversTO+0.5+0.3
Total+3.0+3.1

Each number is standard deviations above or below the top 156 players (a 12-team league's rosters). Field goal and free throw percentage are weighted by attempts, and turnovers count against.

If you punt a category

Punting points, blocks and threes flips the 9-cat answer to Jimmy Butler III.

PuntJimmy Butler IIIKyrie Irving
PTS+2.4 (#15)+1.9 (#18)
REB+3.0 (#14)+4.2 (#11)
AST+2.3 (#19)+2.6 (#16)
STL+1.9 (#25)+2.4 (#19)
BLK+3.8 (#11)+3.6 (#13)
3PM+3.7 (#9)+1.0 (#38)
FG%+2.2 (#22)+3.5 (#14)
FT%+1.5 (#30)+2.3 (#24)
TO+2.5 (#26)+2.8 (#22)

Value is the sum of the other eight z-scores, recomputed with the punted category left out of the pool that sets them; the rank is among all 464 ranked players.

Week 5 (Nov 16-22)

  • Jimmy Butler III: 4 games (Mon @NOP, Wed @DAL, Thu @MEM, Sun BOS), 1 back-to-back, listed Out.
  • Kyrie Irving: 3 games (Wed GSW, Sat LAC, Sun @UTA), 1 back-to-back, listed DTD.

Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving: the Week 5 start/sit call

Recent games

  • Jimmy Butler III: 38.2 fantasy points a game over his last 10 of 2025-26, against 37.4 on the board.
  • Kyrie Irving: 38.4 fantasy points a game over his last 10 of 2026-27, against 36.9 on the board.

Other picks at the same spot

NBA fantasy rankings · Draft cheat sheet · Sleepers

Is Jimmy Butler III playing tonight? · Is Kyrie Irving playing tonight?

Common questions

  • Who is better for the rest of the 2026-27 season, Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving?

    Points leagues: Jimmy Butler III. 37.4 fantasy points per game against 36.9, 38th on our board to 42nd. 9-cat leagues: Kyrie Irving instead, +3.1 in summed z-scores against +3.0 (16th to 17th), because the categories pay for a different mix.

  • Who wins more categories, Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving?

    Category by category, Jimmy Butler III is ahead in 6 (REB, AST, STL, FG%, FT% and TO) and Kyrie Irving in 3 (PTS, BLK and 3PM).

  • Who should I start in Week 5, Jimmy Butler III or Kyrie Irving?

    Jimmy Butler III plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Kyrie Irving 3. For that week alone, start Kyrie Irving: 110.6 projected fantasy points to 0.0 for Jimmy Butler III.

By the Parlae deskBoard updated Nov 17, 2026 at 6:58 AM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number