Skip to main content

John Collins vs Reed Sheppard: who to start in Week 5

John Collins plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Reed Sheppard 3. For that week alone, start John Collins: 94.1 projected fantasy points to 69.3 for Reed Sheppard. Over the season, John Collins leads in points leagues (23.5 fantasy points a game to 23.1) and Reed Sheppard in 9-cat leagues (128th against 147th). The two go close together on our board, which is our own ranking order from 2025-26 and 2026-27 box scores, not ADP.

Updated Nov 17, 5:08 AM ET.

Parlae may earn a commission from price links.

PFCDETage 29
Points leagues
#158
23.5 FP/G, slot 14.02
9-cat leagues
#147
-2.3 z, slot 13.03, $3

The pick in points leagues.

PGSGHOUage 22
Points leagues
#159
23.1 FP/G, slot 14.03
9-cat leagues
#128
-1.9 z, slot 11.08, $5

The pick in 9-cat leagues.

The call

Points leagues: John Collins. 23.5 fantasy points per game against 23.1, 158th on our board to 159th.

9-cat leagues: Reed Sheppard instead, -1.9 in summed z-scores against -2.3 (128th to 147th), because the categories pay for a different mix.

Category by category, John Collins is ahead in 4 (PTS, REB, BLK and FG%) and Reed Sheppard in 4 (AST, STL, 3PM and FT%).

Per 36 minutes, Reed Sheppard produces more: 35.2 fantasy points to 31.6, on 23.6 minutes a night against 26.8. He does it in fewer minutes, so a bigger role would widen the gap.

John Collins plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Reed Sheppard 3. For that week alone, start John Collins: 94.1 projected fantasy points to 69.3 for Reed Sheppard.

Slots are where our board's order lands in a 12-team snake draft (round.pick), and dollars are auction value over replacement for 12 teams with $200 each. Neither is ADP: no free draft-position feed lets us republish it.

Per game, side by side

Per gameJohn CollinsReed Sheppard
Fantasy points per game23.523.1
Minutes26.823.6
PointsPTS12.211.5
ReboundsREB5.62.3
AssistsAST0.93.1
StealsSTL0.71.4
BlocksBLK0.80.4
Threes3PM1.22.5
Field goal %FG%51.2%40.4%
Free throw %FT%75.6%80.2%
TurnoversTO1.21.3
Games, 2025-266982

Bold is the better number. The line blends 2025-26 with 2026-27 games as they are played, the same numbers the rankings use.

Per 36 minutes

Per 36John CollinsReed Sheppard
Fantasy points31.635.2
Points16.317.5
Rebounds7.63.5
Assists1.24.8
Steals0.92.1
Blocks1.10.7
Threes1.73.8
Turnovers1.71.9

Each per-game number divided by minutes and scaled to 36: the rate a bigger role would carry.

9-category z-scores

CategoryJohn CollinsReed Sheppard
PointsPTS-0.8-0.9
ReboundsREB-0.0-1.4
AssistsAST-1.5-0.3
StealsSTL-0.9+0.9
BlocksBLK+0.3-0.5
Threes3PM-0.5+0.8
Field goal percentageFG%+0.5-1.2
Free throw percentageFT%-0.3-0.0
TurnoversTO+0.9+0.8
Total-2.3-1.9

Each number is standard deviations above or below the top 156 players (a 12-team league's rosters). Field goal and free throw percentage are weighted by attempts, and turnovers count against.

If you punt a category

Punting assists, steals and threes flips the 9-cat answer to John Collins.

PuntJohn CollinsReed Sheppard
PTS-1.6 (#138)-1.1 (#114)
REB-2.5 (#152)-0.5 (#81)
AST-0.9 (#91)-1.8 (#137)
STL-1.5 (#120)-2.9 (#186)
BLK-2.9 (#164)-1.5 (#118)
3PM-1.8 (#132)-2.8 (#182)
FG%-3.1 (#167)-0.7 (#79)
FT%-2.0 (#147)-2.0 (#146)
TO-3.3 (#151)-2.8 (#134)

Value is the sum of the other eight z-scores, recomputed with the punted category left out of the pool that sets them; the rank is among all 464 ranked players.

Week 5 (Nov 16-22)

  • John Collins: 4 games (Tue @SAS, Wed @NOP, Fri TOR, Sun @ATL), 1 back-to-back.
  • Reed Sheppard: 3 games (Mon @MIA, Wed @IND, Fri @DEN), 1 back-to-back.

Every team's games this week · Week 5 streamers

Recent games

  • John Collins: 21.0 fantasy points a game over his last 10 of 2026-27, against 23.5 on the board.
  • Reed Sheppard: 16.4 fantasy points a game over his last 10 of 2026-27, against 23.1 on the board.

Other picks at the same spot

NBA fantasy rankings · Draft cheat sheet · Sleepers

Is John Collins playing tonight? · Is Reed Sheppard playing tonight?

Rookie cards: John Collins, Reed Sheppard

Common questions

  • Who is better for the rest of the 2026-27 season, John Collins or Reed Sheppard?

    Points leagues: John Collins. 23.5 fantasy points per game against 23.1, 158th on our board to 159th. 9-cat leagues: Reed Sheppard instead, -1.9 in summed z-scores against -2.3 (128th to 147th), because the categories pay for a different mix.

  • Who wins more categories, John Collins or Reed Sheppard?

    Category by category, John Collins is ahead in 4 (PTS, REB, BLK and FG%) and Reed Sheppard in 4 (AST, STL, 3PM and FT%).

  • Who should I start in Week 5, John Collins or Reed Sheppard?

    John Collins plays 4 games in Week 5 (Nov 16-22), Reed Sheppard 3. For that week alone, start John Collins: 94.1 projected fantasy points to 69.3 for Reed Sheppard.

By the Parlae deskBoard updated Nov 17, 2026 at 5:08 AM ETHow this is builtReport a wrong number