Skip to main content

Week 8 Fantasy Football Start or Sit

Which of two players to start in week 8, and why. Locks at kickoff, graded after.

Week 8 calls

Parlae may earn a commission from price links.

Dyami Brown or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

Charlie Kolar or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Charlie Kolar.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Charlie Kolar. We were right.

Evan Engram or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Evan Engram.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Jadarian Price or RJ Harvey

The call

Start RJ Harvey.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start RJ Harvey. We were wrong.

RJ Harvey or Zach Charbonnet

The call

Start Zach Charbonnet.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Zach Charbonnet. We were right.

RJ Harvey or Saquon Barkley

The call

Start Saquon Barkley.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Saquon Barkley. We were right.

Bam Knight or Jaylen Wright

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Bam Knight or Isaiah Davis

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Bam Knight or Michael Carter

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

Hollywood Brown or Marvin Mims Jr.

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

Hollywood Brown or Jerry Jeudy

The call

Start Jerry Jeudy.

Market-based projection

Jared Goff or Jalon Daniels

The call

Start Jared Goff.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jared Goff. We were right.

Emanuel Wilson or Bam Knight

The call

Start Emanuel Wilson.

Partial market-based projection

Kalif Raymond or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Kalif Raymond.

Market-based projection

We said start Kalif Raymond. We were right.

Tory Horton or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Tory Horton.

Market-based projection

We said start Tory Horton. We were right.

Rashid Shaheed or Tory Horton

The call

Start Tory Horton.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tory Horton. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Malik Washington

The call

Start Malik Washington.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Malik Washington. We were right.

Bam Knight or Justice Hill

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Bam Knight or Keaton Mitchell

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

A.J. Brown or Makai Lemon

The call

Start Makai Lemon.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Makai Lemon. We were right.

Tyler Goodson or Bam Knight

The call

Start Tyler Goodson.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Tyler Goodson. We were right.

Bam Knight or Tyler Allgeier

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Seth McGowan or Bam Knight

The call

Start Seth McGowan.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Seth McGowan. We were right.

Hollywood Brown or Travis Hunter

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

A.J. Brown or Wan'Dale Robinson

The call

Start Wan'Dale Robinson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Wan'Dale Robinson. We were right.

Bam Knight or Corey Kiner

The call

Start Corey Kiner.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Corey Kiner. We were right.

Hollywood Brown or Jauan Jennings

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

Cody White or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

A.J. Brown or Chris Godwin Jr.

The call

Start Chris Godwin Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

George Holani or Bam Knight

The call

Start George Holani.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start George Holani. We were right.

Jahan Dotson or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Jahan Dotson.

Market-based projection

We said start Jahan Dotson. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Elic Ayomanor

The call

Start Elic Ayomanor.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Elic Ayomanor. We were right.

Adonai Mitchell or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Adonai Mitchell.

Market-based projection

We said start Adonai Mitchell. We were right.

Bam Knight or Roschon Johnson

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Tyjae Spears or Tyler Allgeier

The call

Start Tyler Allgeier.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tyler Allgeier. We were right.

Bam Knight or Tyjae Spears

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Kenny Gainwell or Bam Knight

The call

Start Kenny Gainwell.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Kenny Gainwell. We were right.

Kimani Vidal or Bam Knight

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

Jeremy McNichols or Bam Knight

The call

Start Jeremy McNichols.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Jeremy McNichols. We were right.

Bam Knight or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Bam Knight or Dylan Sampson

The call

Start Dylan Sampson.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Dylan Sampson. We were right.

Bam Knight or J.K. Dobbins

The call

Start J.K. Dobbins.

Partial market-based projection

We said start J.K. Dobbins. We were right.

Bam Knight or Samaje Perine

The call

Start Samaje Perine.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Samaje Perine. We were right.

Bam Knight or RJ Harvey

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Bam Knight or Chris Rodriguez Jr.

The call

Start Chris Rodriguez Jr.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Chris Rodriguez Jr.. We were right.

Bam Knight or Omarion Hampton

The call

Start Omarion Hampton.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Omarion Hampton. We were right.

Aaron Jones Sr. or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Aaron Jones Sr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Aaron Jones Sr.. We were right.

Aaron Jones Sr. or Bam Knight

The call

Start Aaron Jones Sr.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Aaron Jones Sr.. We were right.

Bam Knight or Ty Johnson

The call

Start Bam Knight.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Bam Knight. We were wrong.

Bam Knight or Rico Dowdle

The call

Start Rico Dowdle.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Rico Dowdle. We were right.

Calvin Ridley or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Calvin Ridley.

Market-based projection

We said start Calvin Ridley. We were right.

Hollywood Brown or Tez Johnson

The call

Start Tez Johnson.

Market-based projection

Dontayvion Wicks or Laquon Treadwell

The call

Start Laquon Treadwell.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Laquon Treadwell. We were right.

Hollywood Brown or Troy Franklin

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

Hollywood Brown or Jalen Nailor

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

Hollywood Brown or Konata Mumpfield

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

Isaac TeSlaa or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Isaac TeSlaa.

Market-based projection

Kyle Williams or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Kyle Williams.

Market-based projection

We said start Kyle Williams. We were right.

Brian Thomas Jr. or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Hollywood Brown.

Market-based projection

We said start Hollywood Brown. We were wrong.

Elic Ayomanor or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Elic Ayomanor.

Market-based projection

We said start Elic Ayomanor. We were right.

Efton Chism III or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Efton Chism III.

Market-based projection

We said start Efton Chism III. We were right.

Treylon Burks or Hollywood Brown

The call

Start Treylon Burks.

Market-based projection

We said start Treylon Burks. We were right.

Calvin Ridley or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Calvin Ridley.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Calvin Ridley. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Josh Downs

The call

Start Josh Downs.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Josh Downs. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Germie Bernard

The call

Start Germie Bernard.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Germie Bernard. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Xavier Worthy

The call

Start Xavier Worthy.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Xavier Worthy. We were right.

Elic Ayomanor or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Elic Ayomanor.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Elic Ayomanor. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Jahan Dotson

The call

Start Jahan Dotson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jahan Dotson. We were right.

Colby Parkinson or Elijah Higgins

The call

Start Colby Parkinson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Colby Parkinson. We were wrong.

Kyle Williams or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Kyle Williams.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kyle Williams. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Kalif Raymond

The call

Start Kalif Raymond.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kalif Raymond. We were right.

Emeka Egbuka or Rashee Rice

The call

Start Rashee Rice.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Rashee Rice. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Rashee Rice

The call

Start Rashee Rice.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Rashee Rice. We were right.

Dontayvion Wicks or Jalen Royals

The call

Start Jalen Royals.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jalen Royals. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Keenan Allen

The call

Start Keenan Allen.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Keenan Allen. We were right.

Seth McGowan or Tyjae Spears

The call

Start Seth McGowan.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Seth McGowan. We were right.

Seth McGowan or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Seth McGowan.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Seth McGowan. We were right.

Dylan Sampson or Tyjae Spears

The call

Start Dylan Sampson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Dylan Sampson. We were right.

Dylan Sampson or RJ Harvey

The call

Start Dylan Sampson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Dylan Sampson. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Dylan Sampson

The call

Start Dylan Sampson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Dylan Sampson. We were right.

Dylan Sampson or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Dylan Sampson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Dylan Sampson. We were right.

Corey Kiner or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Corey Kiner.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Corey Kiner. We were right.

Charlie Kolar or Colby Parkinson

The call

Start Charlie Kolar.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Charlie Kolar. We were right.

RJ Harvey or Pierre Strong Jr.

The call

Start RJ Harvey.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start RJ Harvey. We were wrong.

Kimani Vidal or RJ Harvey

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

Jeremy McNichols or RJ Harvey

The call

Start Jeremy McNichols.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jeremy McNichols. We were right.

RJ Harvey or Samaje Perine

The call

Start Samaje Perine.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Samaje Perine. We were right.

Kenny Gainwell or RJ Harvey

The call

Start Kenny Gainwell.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kenny Gainwell. We were right.

Kaleb Johnson or Kimani Vidal

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

Kimani Vidal or Tyjae Spears

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

By Parlae Analysis DeskCalls updated Nov 4, 2026 at 7:53 AM ET

The Parlae Analysis Desk turns the site's market-based projections, snap and target shares and injury reports into weekly start/sit and comparison calls. Every call is graded after the games on the public record, wrong ones included. More about the desk.

Week 8 by position

Other weeks

Common questions

  • Who should I start in week 8?

    This page lists every start or sit call we published for week 8, two players at a time, each with the verdict, the deciding numbers and the reasoning on its own page.

  • When do week 8 start/sit calls lock?

    Locks at kickoff, graded after. The verdict and the numbers that decided it stay on the page, and each call is graded once the games are scored.

  • How does Parlae make its start/sit calls?

    Every call starts from market-based projections, each player's usage (snap and target shares), and the matchup (his opponent's points allowed to the position). Nothing is invented: when the books have not priced a player, the page says so instead of guessing.

  • Where can I check whether the calls were right?

    Every graded call is on our public record, wrong ones included, with the result marked on the page it was called on.