Skip to main content

Week 9 Fantasy Football Start or Sit

Which of two players to start in week 9, and why. Locks at kickoff, graded after.

Week 9 calls

Parlae may earn a commission from price links.

Joe Milton III or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Joe Milton III.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Joe Milton III. We were right.

Matthew Stafford or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Matthew Stafford.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Matthew Stafford. We were right.

Garrett Wilson or Ryan Flournoy

The call

Start Ryan Flournoy.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Ryan Flournoy. We were right.

Carson Wentz or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Carson Wentz.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Carson Wentz. We were wrong.

Efton Chism III or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Efton Chism III.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Efton Chism III. We were right.

Darius Cooper or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Darius Cooper.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Darius Cooper. We were right.

Chris Godwin Jr. or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Chris Godwin Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Chris Godwin Jr.. We were right.

Treylon Burks or Xavier Worthy

The call

Start Xavier Worthy.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Xavier Worthy. We were right.

MarShawn Lloyd or Sean Tucker

The call

Start Sean Tucker.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Brian Robinson or Samaje Perine

The call

Start Samaje Perine.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Samaje Perine. We were right.

Quentin Johnston or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Quentin Johnston.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Quentin Johnston. We were right.

Tre Tucker or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Tre Tucker.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tre Tucker. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Kaelon Black

The call

Start Kaelon Black.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kaelon Black. We were right.

Cam Skattebo or Kaelon Black

The call

Start Kaelon Black.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kaelon Black. We were right.

Rashid Shaheed or Tre' Harris

The call

Start Tre' Harris.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tre' Harris. We were right.

Emanuel Wilson or Ty Johnson

The call

Start Emanuel Wilson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Emanuel Wilson. We were wrong.

Brian Robinson or Corey Kiner

The call

Start Corey Kiner.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Corey Kiner. We were right.

Chris Rodriguez Jr. or MarShawn Lloyd

The call

Start MarShawn Lloyd.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start MarShawn Lloyd. We were wrong.

Jordan Watkins or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Jordan Watkins.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jordan Watkins. We were right.

Josh Downs or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Josh Downs.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Josh Downs. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Keenan Allen

The call

Start Keenan Allen.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Keenan Allen. We were right.

Breece Hall or Brian Robinson

The call

Start Breece Hall.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Breece Hall. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Seth McGowan

The call

Start Seth McGowan.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Seth McGowan. We were right.

Cam Skattebo or Seth McGowan

The call

Start Seth McGowan.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Seth McGowan. We were right.

Braelon Allen or Brian Robinson

The call

Start Braelon Allen.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Braelon Allen. We were right.

Braelon Allen or Cam Skattebo

The call

Start Braelon Allen.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Braelon Allen. We were right.

Breece Hall or Cam Skattebo

The call

Start Breece Hall.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Breece Hall. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Kimani Vidal

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

CJ Donaldson or Keaton Mitchell

The call

Start Keaton Mitchell.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Keaton Mitchell. We were right.

Tre' Harris or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Tre' Harris.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tre' Harris. We were right.

Rashid Shaheed or Xavier Hutchinson

The call

Start Xavier Hutchinson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Xavier Hutchinson. We were right.

J.K. Dobbins or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start J.K. Dobbins.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start J.K. Dobbins. We were right.

Bhayshul Tuten or Cam Skattebo

The call

Start Bhayshul Tuten.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Bhayshul Tuten. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Keaton Mitchell

The call

Start Keaton Mitchell.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Keaton Mitchell. We were right.

TreVeyon Henderson or Tyler Goodson

The call

Start Tyler Goodson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tyler Goodson. We were right.

Garrett Wilson or Jaxon Smith-Njigba

The call

Start Jaxon Smith-Njigba.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jaxon Smith-Njigba. We were right.

Courtland Sutton or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Courtland Sutton.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Courtland Sutton. We were right.

Joe Milton III or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Joe Milton III.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Joe Milton III. We were right.

Aaron Jones Sr. or TreVeyon Henderson

The call

Start Aaron Jones Sr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Aaron Jones Sr.. We were right.

Drew Lock or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Drew Lock.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Drew Lock. We were right.

Rashid Shaheed or Tez Johnson

The call

Start Tez Johnson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tez Johnson. We were right.

Cam Skattebo or Kenny Gainwell

The call

Start Kenny Gainwell.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kenny Gainwell. We were right.

Gardner Minshew II or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Gardner Minshew II.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Gardner Minshew II. We were right.

Drew Lock or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Drew Lock.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Drew Lock. We were right.

Brian Robinson or Jordan Mason

The call

Start Jordan Mason.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jordan Mason. We were right.

Chris Rodriguez Jr. or Brian Robinson

The call

Start Chris Rodriguez Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Chris Rodriguez Jr.. We were right.

CJ Donaldson or Kimani Vidal

The call

Start Kimani Vidal.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kimani Vidal. We were right.

J.J. McCarthy or Sam Darnold

The call

Start J.J. McCarthy.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start J.J. McCarthy. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Justin Jefferson

The call

Start Justin Jefferson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Justin Jefferson. We were right.

A.J. Brown or Malik Nabers

The call

Start Malik Nabers.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Malik Nabers. We were right.

Michael Penix Jr. or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Michael Penix Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Michael Penix Jr.. We were right.

Caleb Douglas or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Caleb Douglas.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Caleb Douglas. We were right.

Jahan Dotson or Treylon Burks

The call

Start Jahan Dotson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jahan Dotson. We were right.

Marvin Harrison Jr. or Rashid Shaheed

The call

Start Marvin Harrison Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Marvin Harrison Jr.. We were right.

By Parlae Analysis DeskCalls updated Nov 11, 2026 at 7:53 AM ET

The Parlae Analysis Desk turns the site's market-based projections, snap and target shares and injury reports into weekly start/sit and comparison calls. Every call is graded after the games on the public record, wrong ones included. More about the desk.

Week 9 by position

Other weeks

Common questions

  • Who should I start in week 9?

    This page lists every start or sit call we published for week 9, two players at a time, each with the verdict, the deciding numbers and the reasoning on its own page.

  • When do week 9 start/sit calls lock?

    Locks at kickoff, graded after. The verdict and the numbers that decided it stay on the page, and each call is graded once the games are scored.

  • How does Parlae make its start/sit calls?

    Every call starts from market-based projections, each player's usage (snap and target shares), and the matchup (his opponent's points allowed to the position). Nothing is invented: when the books have not priced a player, the page says so instead of guessing.

  • Where can I check whether the calls were right?

    Every graded call is on our public record, wrong ones included, with the result marked on the page it was called on.