Skip to main content

Week 9 quarterback start or sit

Which quarterbacks to start in week 9, and why.

Almost all of a quarterback's points come from passing yards and passing touchdowns, so the weekly call usually turns on the matchup and the pace of the game rather than on volume.

Week 9 quarterback calls

Parlae may earn a commission from price links.

Joe Milton III or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Joe Milton III.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Joe Milton III. We were right.

Matthew Stafford or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Matthew Stafford.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Matthew Stafford. We were right.

Carson Wentz or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Carson Wentz.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Carson Wentz. We were wrong.

Joe Milton III or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Joe Milton III.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Joe Milton III. We were right.

Drew Lock or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Drew Lock.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Drew Lock. We were right.

Gardner Minshew II or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Gardner Minshew II.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Gardner Minshew II. We were right.

Drew Lock or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Drew Lock.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Drew Lock. We were right.

J.J. McCarthy or Sam Darnold

The call

Start J.J. McCarthy.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start J.J. McCarthy. We were right.

Michael Penix Jr. or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Michael Penix Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Michael Penix Jr.. We were right.

Joe Fagnano or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Joe Fagnano.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Joe Fagnano. We were right.

Daniel Jones or Kyler Murray

The call

Start Daniel Jones.

Market-based projection

We said start Daniel Jones. We were right.

Deshaun Watson or Joe Fagnano

The call

Start Deshaun Watson.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Deshaun Watson. We were wrong.

Gardner Minshew II or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Gardner Minshew II.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Gardner Minshew II. We were right.

Kyler Murray or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Kyler Murray.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Jordan Love or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Jordan Love.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Jordan Love. We were right.

C.J. Stroud or Sam Darnold

The call

Start C.J. Stroud.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start C.J. Stroud. We were right.

Bryce Young or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Bryce Young.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Bryce Young. We were right.

Baker Mayfield or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Baker Mayfield.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Baker Mayfield. We were right.

Tanner McKee or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Tanner McKee.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Bryce Young or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Bryce Young.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Bryce Young. We were right.

Sam Darnold or Tanner McKee

The call

Start Tanner McKee.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Justin Herbert or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Justin Herbert.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Justin Herbert. We were right.

Daniel Jones or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Daniel Jones.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Daniel Jones. We were right.

Daniel Jones or Deshaun Watson

The call

Start Daniel Jones.

Partial market-based projection

We said start Daniel Jones. We were right.

Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Baker Mayfield.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Baker Mayfield. We were right.

Sam Darnold or Tyler Shough

The call

Start Tyler Shough.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Tyler Shough. We were right.

Patrick Mahomes or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Patrick Mahomes.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Patrick Mahomes. We were right.

Michael Penix Jr. or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Michael Penix Jr.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Michael Penix Jr.. We were right.

Trevor Lawrence or Jacoby Brissett

The call

Start Trevor Lawrence.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Trevor Lawrence. We were right.

Justin Herbert or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Justin Herbert.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Justin Herbert. We were right.

Daniel Jones or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Daniel Jones.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Daniel Jones. We were right.

Geno Smith or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Geno Smith.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Geno Smith. We were right.

Malik Willis or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Malik Willis.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Malik Willis. We were right.

Geno Smith or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Geno Smith.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Geno Smith. We were right.

Sam Darnold or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Sam Darnold.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Malik Willis or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Malik Willis.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Malik Willis. We were right.

Kirk Cousins or Tyler Huntley

The call

Start Kirk Cousins.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kirk Cousins. We were right.

Kirk Cousins or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Kirk Cousins.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Kirk Cousins. We were right.

Deshaun Watson or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Sam Darnold.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

Bo Nix or Sam Darnold

The call

Start Bo Nix.

Market-based projection, from recent weeks where this week's market is not posted yet

We said start Bo Nix. We were right.

Bo Nix or Josh Allen

The call

Start Josh Allen.

Market-based projection

We said start Josh Allen. We were wrong.

Daniel Jones or Carson Wentz

The call

Start Daniel Jones.

Market-based projection

We said start Daniel Jones. We were right.

Week 9, other slots

All week 9 calls